A white police officer in Grand Rapids, Michigan has been charged with second-degree murder for shooting Patrick Lyoya, a 26-year-old black man he had stopped for a traffic violation. The father of the dead man says, “We strongly believed there was no justice in America, until today,” he said. Attorney Ben Crump, ubiquitous spokesman in these cases, remarks that he’s “encouraged” by the police officer’s arrest:
“While the road to justice for Patrick and his family has just begun, this decision is a crucial step in the right direction,” Crump said. “Officer Schurr must be held accountable for his decision to pursue an unarmed Patrick, ultimately shooting him in the back of the head and killing him – for nothing more than a traffic stop.”
Ben Crump is a continual liar and race-mongering rabble rouser. In case after case, he gets in early and speaks often, quoted in the MSM as though he’s stating the facts of the case truthfully. In this case he’s setting the scene for the American people, and he knows that the sooner and more unequivocally he speaks the better, and that the media will help him out in setting out a narrative that will be hard to correct in the future and will hopefully taint the jury pool.
So here we have the usual “unarmed” black man, cruelly murdered in cold blood for “nothing more than a traffic stop.” Isn’t that a story that should make your blood boil?
Except that in the hearing a different story was told, and this one appears to be backed up by video evidence:
Schurr’s attorneys said in a motion for bond the officer saw the Nissan Lyoya was driving “moving suspiciously slowly and thought it matched the description of a recently reported stolen vehicle.” He “ran” the car’s plate and realized it didn’t match the car, which led him to believe the car might be stolen.
That’s already not just a traffic stop, it’s a special kind of traffic stop – for possible stolen car as well as possible driving while impaired.
Next:
Michigan State Police Det. Sgt. Aaron Tubergen, whose agency investigated the shooting, said in a court document supporting the arrest warrant Lyoya tried to get away from Schurr after the officer asked for his license and traveled about 30 feet from the car before being tackled to the ground.
Oh, so Lyoya fled? More [emphasis mine]:
There was a physical altercation, with Schurr demanding Lyoya, “stop fighting, stop resisting,” according to a transcript of Tubergen’s testimony Thursday morning to the judge who signed off on the second-degree murder charge and the warrant.
Tubergen said Schurr deployed his Taser twice [although it didn’t contact Lyoya]. After Lyoya gained control of the Taser, Schurr made “many commands” for him to drop the device and a physical altercation followed with both men on the ground.
The officer was on top of Lyoya’s back — the Black man prone on the ground — when Schurr “lost complete control of the Taser.” Lyoya had “complete control of the Taser” at that point.
Oh, so Lyoya got the taser, which means he could use it to tase Schurr and disable him, and then grab his weapon and shoot him or someone else? That seems to me to put Schurr in valid fear for his life. And that’s when Schurr shot him in the back of the head:
“It appears that Patrick was then on his hands and knees. Again, Officer Schurr was on his back,” the detective sergeant said, according to the transcript. “Officer Schurr pulled his duty firearm from its holster and then fired one round into the back of Patrick’s head, causing his body to go limp.”
Tubergen told the Kent County judge he interviewed law enforcement, reviewed body camera footage, dash camera video, residential security video from the neighborhood and a cellphone video recorded by a witness.
More facts may come out – probably will come out – that could modify this account. They might exonerate Schurr further, or they might point more to his guilt. But there is little question that Schurr did not suddenly and for no reason kill Lyoya in a routine traffic stop.
Also:
Lyoya had three outstanding warrants at the time he fled Schurr, and an autopsy revealed his blood-alcohol concentration was more than three times the legal limit.
Warrants for what? Here’s a bit more about that:
According to an account in MLive, Lyoya had a revoked license and outstanding warrant for his arrest when he was pulled over. He also had an arrest warrant issued April 1 for a domestic violence charge at the time of the traffic stop.
More:
Lyoya’s death prompted calls by some for Grand Rapids police to curtail police stops for routine violations, following the lead of Lansing police who no longer pull motorists over for minor violations such as a cracked taillight or ornament hanging from a mirror.
Which has zero to do with this case or this traffic stop, which was not for a mirror ornament.
Much more at the link, such as:
A 2020 national study of more than 100 million traffic stops found that Black drivers were 20 percent more likely to be stopped than white drivers relative to their share of the residential population. Black drivers also were 1.5 times more likely to be searched than white drivers, though they were less likely to be carrying drugs or guns.
Is it possible, just possible, that black drivers might be committing more traffic violations? Is it possible they are searched because – like Lyoya and so many others in these incidents – a check shows they have outstanding warrants or have no license? And those guns the white people are carrying in greater numbers – are they legal? Just curious.
Second-degree murder carries a possible life sentence in Michigan. And the activist community has already said that Schurr must be convicted and put away for life.
[NOTE: Lyoya does not appear to have been a citizen, although that’s not very clear. His family came here from the Democratic Republic of the Congo in 2014, when he would have been about 18 years old.]