…that the law is an ass.
Is there no way for the Obama administration to stop huge amounts of taxpayer money from getting to the very executives responsible (or irresponsible) for making such lousy and self-serving decisions, and bringing us all to this sorry pass? The answer is: apparently not.
This is not just a shot at just the Obama administration, by the way. The bailouts were a bipartisan endeavor, begun—in a great hurry—by the Bush administration in concert with the Democratic-controlled Congress. Haste makes waste, as they say, and there seem to have been a paucity of restrictions on what the companies could actually do with that money.
At the time of the AIG bailout, the crisis was billed as one that had to be acted on immediately or the entire financial system would go down. I have my doubts about that, but who knows?
And who was willing to risk it and see? We don’t have an alternate reality in which to test what would have been the result of delay.
I’ll repeat the very wise words of author Milan Kundera on the impossibility of ever knowing the consequences of having done something different:
There is only one history of the Czechs…
In 1618, the Czech estates took courage and vented their ire on the emperor reigning in Vienna by pitching two of his high officials out of a window in the Prague Castle. Their defiance led to the Thirty Years War, which in turn led to the almost complete destruction of the Czech nation. Should the Czechs have shown more caution than courage? The answer may seem simple; it is not.
Three hundred and twenty years later, after the Munich Conference of 1938, the entire world decided to sacrifice the Czech’s country to Hitler. Should the Czechs have tried to stand up to a power eight times their size? In countrast to 1618, they opted for caution. Their capitulation led to the Second World War, which in turn led to the forfeit of their nation’s freedom for many decades or even centuries. What should they have done?
If Czech history could be repeated, we should of course find it desirable to check the other possibility each time and compare the results. Without such an experiment, all considerations of this kind remain a game of hypotheses”¦
The history of the Czechs will not be repeated, nor will the history of all of Europe. The history of the Czechs and of Europe are a pair of sketches from the pen of mankind’s fateful inexperience.
Not to mention the history of America, and of the world. “Mankind’s fateful inexperience.” I love it.
[NOTE: Here’s an explanation for why it might make sense to pay the price—apparently, these AIG hacks may be the only people who can unwind this mess. What a sad state of affairs.
Here’s a comment that’s pretty on-target:
Basically, $100 million is something like 0.1% of the money that’s tied up in these trades. We the people now owe 80% of AIG. Having new folks try to understand the deals and clumsily unwind them will cost us a lot more than 0.1% of their value, so it’s cheaper to just pay the bastards their money and have them do it.
I’m somewhat more attracted to an alternative where we enslave these people for six months and make them unwind the trades for nothing. But that’s neither legal nor feasible…]
[ADDENDUM: Evidence that the Left is far from happy about this state of affairs, as well. And Obama seems to be hearing it—or at least making a show of hearing it.]
[NOTE: My spam filter seems to be overactive today. Bear with me as I try to fix the problem.]
[UPDATE: There doesn’t seem to be any reason these comments aren’t going through properly. My best guess is that it is something about this particular post rather than a generalized problem. Keep trying to post comments, and I will re-post them if they fail to show up, because they are showing up in my spam filter. If the difficulty continues, I’ll have to make some sort of a more general change.]







