I’m rather fond of dogs. But I can’t quite imagine cloning a beloved pet to the tune of $155,000.
Some people can, though. And not only can they imagine it, but they’ve paid to have it done.
Is this the height of decadence, denial of death, or devotion? You be the judge; I personally think it’s a bit of all three, including a hefty dose of the demented.
After all, a dog is—like most living creatures of any complexity—not a mere function of heredity. Environment plays a role, and so even by cloning you won’t necessarily get old Fido back, as some have already learned who’ve tried. There are also minor cosmetic variations that represent the result of characteristics of the uterine environment.
Lou Hawthorne is in charge of the San Francisco-based (where else?) endeavor, which he claims is the first to commercially clone dogs. The trailblazer was Missy, his mother’s beloved border collie/husky mix, from whom four clones have been produced.
Hawthorne’s 8-year old son Skye has gotten a pretty nice science project out of the process. But strangely enough, Hawthorne’s mother isn’t impressed with the results of the cloning:
“They’re not at all alike,” Ms. Hawthorne said of the old Missy and the new one. “In looks, they are a little bit, of course. But, I mean, the puppy is delicate and aggressive. Missy was robust and completely calm.” She added, “Missy wouldn’t come through my home and knock over every wineglass.”
Besides, she adopted another puppy not long after Missy died. “I already have a dog ”” a real dog.”
Ms. Hawthorne is mistaken about one thing: Missy’s clones are as “real” as any other dogs, despite their odd origins. But she’s not the only one who’s a bit confused. A Florida man who paid $155,000 for the thrill of having a clone of his deceased canine companion Lancelot had this to say about it:
Cloning means you could have the opportunity to have the same dog with you for your entire life.
No, Mr. Otto, just ask Ms. Hawthorne. It’s not the same dog over and over, any more than identical twins are the same person. Otto may be in for a few disappointments if he thinks otherwise.