Wow, I didn’t see this coming. Not that I was paying close attention, because my impression was that Brat didn’t have a chance:
House Majority Leader Eric Cantor lost in his Republican primary election Tuesday to a little-known economics professor, a stunning upset for the GOP’s No. 2 in the House and a major victory for the tea party.
Cantor, viewed as a possible successor to House Speaker John Boehner, was taken down by a political novice with little money named Dave Brat. His win marked the biggest triumph this year for tea party supporters who until a few years ago backed Cantor, a former state legislator who rose to Majority Leader in 2011.
Since immigration and amnesty were huge issues in this race, I wonder how much the story that just broke the other day—about the masses of illegal immigrant children overwhelming Arizona and Texas, and being released into the community—affected the results in Cantor’s district. My sense is that it had to have had a pretty big effect, and maybe even made the difference in the race. Cantor has been a less than strong presence in Congress as a leader, too Mr. Nice Guy and not perceived as a fighter. Right now I think the mood is for a fighter.
What is a little odd is that Brat actually has a mild-mannered professorial demeanor, like Cantor (and in fact, he is a professor—of economics) and even slightly resembles Cantor physically:
In other news, Lindsay Graham has won his primary in South Carolina. So it’s hard to see any patterns in the whole thing.
The commentators on Fox have all been saying this means amnesty is dead in the House. I’m not sure, but they’re also saying it probably doesn’t matter because President Obama has made it pretty clear that if Congress doesn’t give him what he wants re immigration he’ll do it himself. What a guy! If he does that, it will one of the very worst things he has done in terms of domestic policy and Constitutional overreach (and that’s saying a lot). It would make it more clear than ever that he is assuming dictatorial powers. No doubt he considers it worth it, though, because getting all those new Democratic voters into the country takes top priority. Never mind if he starts a civil war in the process.
I really, really hope the prognosticators who say Obama will now go the phone/pen route are wrong. But I think it much more likely that they are right. Remember how everyone (including me) was celebrating Scott Brown’s victory in Massachusetts in early 2010 because they thought it meant the end of Obamacare in the Senate? Turns out it only meant that Obama and the Democrats would have to be more creative about getting what they wanted.
[ADDENDUM: If Brat does get elected, he sounds as though he’ll be one of the most interesting and unique members of the House. Here’s part of his resume:
Dave Brat presents a major problem for liberals who try to continue increased government spending by discrediting conservatives and claiming the budget is “too complicated” for conservatives to understand….
A product of the rural Midwest, he learned the value of faith, family, and a strong work ethic at a young age. Dave was determined to get an education that would empower him to help others reach their economic dreams.
Dave’s journey led him to Princeton where he obtained a Masters in Divinity and on to American University where he earned a Ph.D. in Economics. That education has led him to a career serving the Commonwealth.
In 1996, Dave and Laura moved to Henrico and he began teaching Economics and Ethics at Randolph-Macon College, and he chaired the Economics and Business department for the past 6 years.
That’s quite a combination.]
[ADDENDUM II: Looking at Brat, I think another reason Brat won was because,unlike many such challengers, he’s a good candidate: smart, not wacky, an appealing person who comes across as honest and sincere. That said, he couldn’t scare up even much Tea Party support prior to tonight.
For those conservatives who turned their backs on Ann Coulter during the 2012 election as an “establishment Republican” because she championed the supposed RINO [sic] Romney, note that she was one of the few big names who supported Brat in this race.]
[ADDENDUM III: A list of Brat’s scholarly publications.]



