Supposedly as a result of the recent action in Gaza by the Israelis, anti-Semitism is rising around the world—or at least, demonstrations of anti-Semitism are rising.
But Ron Fournier has been deeply asleep if he thinks the anti-Israel press is new. It was already very deeply entrenched when I started paying close attention after 2001. The Al Durah incident and its resultant worldwide anti-Israel propaganda occurred even before that, and was one of the worst offenses; Jenin was in 2002. I’ve written about both at great length on this blog.
The Palestinians and Islamic terrorists and their sympathizers around the world learned long ago that one of the best propaganda methods for reaching liberals of the west was the dead child and the grieving family. And so, not only are such civilians killed as the inevitable collateral damage of war exploited for propaganda purposes, but even if it is actually the Arab world causing the damage to its own people by accident, that is blamed on the Israelis and exploited, as well.
Did I say “by accident”? Surely that occurs sometimes. But somewhere along the line—and quite a long time ago, too—the Palestinians graduated to using techniques of asymmetrical warfare in order to purposely cause more casualties of that exact nature, in order to parade them before the world as fodder for propaganda. Chief among such cynically evil tactics are storing armaments among civilians, including (or perhaps especially) in family homes, schools, and hospitals, and then parading the victims before an Arab and western press willing and eager to spread the word. Thus, the press shares some of the culpability for these deaths.
Some of this was exposed many years ago, and more than once. But much of the MSM hasn’t cared that in the past so many Palestinian reports of civilian deaths at Israeli hands have turned out to be lies of one sort or another. They still all-too-often report without caveats what the Palestinians say during such conflicts, knowing that the corrections they so frequently have to offer (if they bother to acknowledge their errors at all) almost never filter down to the majority of the public. That’s why a great many in the MSM still consider these lies very much worth telling, because no matter what contradictory facts later reports may reveal, these lies have for the most part become the public’s perception of the truth.
Thus, in the recent fighting in Gaza, we have this correction of a false report of Israeli wrongdoing (also discussed at Powerline). Volokh writes:
The media has engaged in journalistic malpractice by reporting casualty figures for civilians coming from Gaza as gospel. The figures come from the Gazan Ministry of Health, which is controlled by Hamas. The Ministry of Health counts everyone not in uniform as a civilian. Most Hamas fighters don’t wear uniforms. The UN is sometimes sourced for the figures, but the UN gets its figures from ”¦ the Gazan Ministry of Health. Contrary to early reports that 80% or so of the early casualties were civilians, Al-Jazeera published names and ages, and about 3/4 were men of fighting age (16-50), compared to a rough estimate of 20% of the Gazan population (40% to 50% of which is fourteen and under). Some of those men were undoubtedly civilians, but it strains credulity to believe that 80% of the casualties were civilian but just-so-happened to be overwhelmingly fighting-age men. (Here’s the most recent analysis from the IsraellyCool blog). For that matter, how do we know that the Minsitry of Health isn’t counting deaths from natural causes as deaths from Israeli actions? A simple “the Hamas-controlled Gaza Ministry of Health claims” before reciting casualty figures that the media has not itself verified would resolve the problem.
Remember Jenin?:
”¦the U.N. report said 52 Palestinian deaths had been confirmed by April 18””the same death toll reported by Israel. It called the Palestinian allegation that some 500 were killed “a figure that has not been substantiated in the light of evidence that has emerged.”
Seeing the mendacity of the reporting about that battle, and the paucity of meaningful retractions of the false reports, as well as the lies’ lasting influence, was one of many incidents in my political change experience.
With the continuation of similar events, one could ask the old “fool or knave?” question, this time as applied to the press. Whether or not a reporter on board with this is consciously lying or is unaware he/she has been duped and manipulated into telling lies, at this point every reporter should be aware of the entire process and how common it is. After Jenin, when even the Israel-hating UN substantiated the Israeli claims and unfounded the Palestinian ones, there is no excuse for not being extremely careful to make sure that the casualty figures are correct, and to be extremely suspicious of the initial Palestinian reports. One can only conclude that when that doesn’t occur, the press is either purposefully lying or acting with reckless disregard for the truth.
The UN is a player in Gaza, too. Just as the final UN report on Jenin exonerated the Israelis, long after lies accusing the Israelis of barbarism there had been successfully promulgated around the world, the UN periodically issues small announcements which implicate the Palestinians in Gaza now. For example, we have the third report of rockets found in Palestinian schools in Gaza administered by the UN. Now, how do you suppose they got there? The UN is mum on the subject:
The United Nations Relief & Works Agency For Palestine Refugees (UNRWA) announced Tuesday that another rocket stockpile has been found at one of its schools in Gaza. This instance marks the third time since the beginning of Operation Protective Edge that a weapons arsenal has been found at an UNRWA school in Gaza.
UNRWA has yet to place blame on any individuals or organizations for placing the weapons stockpile within a children’s school. The UN body refused to do so on the past two previous occasions as well.
The UN body, after both previous findings, has handed the rockets it had found back into the possession of “the local police,” otherwise known as the terrorist group Hamas.
Does anyone believe these rockets won’t go back more or less where they came from?
It’s no surprise that Israel does so poorly in the propaganda wars, with so much stacked against it. And yet ignoring those wars is not the answer, either. Israel itself and its spokespeople have been slow on the draw and fairly inept at dealing with it, too. I’ve noticed a slight improvement this time around from Israel—their disclaimers of responsibility seem to be coming faster, anyway.
[ADDENDUM: In addition, some journalists are also intimidated by the Palestinians into reporting as they are ordered.]