[UPDATED further below]
Trump has made a statement, and a lot of video has emerged, on the incident where Trump campaign manager Corey Lewandowski is alleged to have grabbed Breitbart reporter Michelle Fields by the arm and thrown her to the floor.
As usual, Trump has accused the accuser:
Republican presidential front-runner Donald Trump accused Breitbart reporter Michelle Fields of fabricating her accusation that his campaign manager grabbed her hard enough to leave a bruise during a campaign event.
“Perhaps she made the story up. I think that’s what happened,” Trump told reporters after Thursday night’s GOP debate in Miami of Tuesday night’s alleged incident.
In a later statement issued Friday morning, the Trump campaign said the accusation is “entirely false” and that the staff had “no knowledge of said situation.”…
The Jupiter Police Department confirmed to NBC News on Friday that a police report about the incident has been filed and that an investigation is ongoing.
…The Trump campaign manager attacked Fields in a series of tweets, calling her an “attention” seeker ”” which prompted the journalist to tweet a picture of her bruised arm.
Lewandowski later continued to tweet about Fields, calling her an “attention seeker” and questioning her journalistic integrity.
Trump’s campaign spokeswoman Hope Hicks also cast aspersions on Fields’ reporting, saying in a statement that the Breitbart reporter had “never met” Lewandowski.
After that statement, Breitbart said it was “disappointed” in the campaign’s response and “in particular their effort to demean” Fields’ previous reporting.
This despite the evidence of a bruise on Fields’ arm, and an audio that supports her charge (it’s of Fields and a WaPo reporter witness talking immediately afterwards).
Today there are also multiple videos emerging. None show a crystal clear view of the exact moment the incident occurred, but they show enough that the following seems clear:
(1) Some incident of the sort occurred; Fields does not seem to be making anything up in that regard.
(2) It was either at the hands of Lewandowski (most likely) or possibly a security guard right next to him, or both:
More video airing at The Daily Beast. Ben Terris [the WaPo reporter witness] followed along and maintained an excellent vantage point (I always check the position of the refs during these endless booth reviews). C Lewandowski clearly reached for Fields’ arm as the group passed behind the same damn obstacle. Possible remaining spin – the security guy, presumably Secret Service, finished the job that C Lew ineffectually began.
Well. The call on the field is that C Lew grabbed her. Pending more video, there is nowhere near enough to overturn that.
This incident reflects on Trump in two ways. The first is that, if Fields is correct in the identification of Lewandowski as the person who grabbed her arm and threw her down, Trump’s contention about choosing “the best people” is suspect. Of course, I suppose it depends on how he would answer the question “best at what?” And the other way it matters is (as I contended in my first post on the subject) what is shows about Trump’s reactions and instincts.
His first reaction (and usually his second, third, fourth, and fifth, and on and on) is to blame the other person. And not just to blame the person for error (that would not be so bad on Trump’s part), but to cast aspersions on the person’s veracity, motives, and character. Now, some may think this is just an example of Trump’s ability to fight. I’d say it’s just another in many examples of his thin skin, poor character, ability to fight dirty, and vengeful retaliatory nature. This may have worked for him quite nicely as celebrity and builder but it bodes ill for the rest of us in terms of his behavior if he were to gain the enormous power of the highest office in the land.
Another interesting thing is to see Trump’s followers make excuses for him and jump on the bandwagon to attack Fields and/or to say the media deserves it anyway (which is pretty weird, since Breitbart has been Trump’s greatest booster). Go to any blog that attracts a lot of Trump supporters and you’ll have no trouble seeing what I’m talking about.
It seems that no one—including the Big Guy—would ever say something like, “I stand behind my campaign manager and believe he is innocent and Fields mistaken, but if evidence comes out that such a thing did happen then I would of course condemn it.” I realize that Trump would consider such a statement a sign of weakness, and against his usual strategy of denial and character assassination. I’m wondering whether he’s ever tracked back anything in his life.
[ADDENDUM: More video emerges.]
[ADDENDUM II: Ace has an excellent post on the subject, and in another post of his about it he writes, “I didn’t join the conservative movement to become a fascist.” Ace, by the way, is another changer.]
[UPDATE 3/14: Even more video has surfaced which purports to show the moment of contact involved, and does not involve a push of the magnitude alleged. Since there were supposedly two moments of contact (at least that’s what I read earlier) shown on other videos, I’m not sure what this new video proves or disproves, or where it fits into the sequence. Nor was I sure what the previous videos showed, either.
Again, just to sum up what we know: there was some sort of touching, or perhaps two touchings. Did either involve a squeeze hard enough to bruise? Or to almost push Fields down? Certainly nothing of that sort is shown on any of the videos, but Trump’s campaign manager does seem to have touched Fields.
I’ve never been able to figure out what happened, and I still am not, but my primary interest in the entire thing is Trump’s reaction. Earlier in this post I suggested what I think he should have said, a response which would have denied any wrongdoing on the part of Lewandowski but would have caused scarcely a ripple of controversy. I repeat it here: “I stand behind my campaign manager and believe he is innocent and Fields mistaken, but if evidence comes out that such a thing did happen then I would of course condemn it.”]