First let’s look at the transcript of the speech (sorry it’s a link to CNN, but they’re the ones providing it right now, so they’re definitely good for something).
And here’s the way the leftist press (the Guardian, in this case) is covering it [emphasis mine]:
At the start of a four-day trip to Europe, the US president gave a highly nationalist address in Warsaw suggesting that a lack of collective resolve could doom an alliance that had endured through the cold war.
How can a highly nationalist speech emphasize collective resolve? Is that not a contradiction? Isn’t a nationalist speech one that talks about how great a certain nation is, and would preclude “collective” action rather than prescribe it?
But the words “nationalist” and “nationalistic” has to come to be a code word to the left meaning bigoted and racist, jingoistic and backward. I wrote about that idea in this post of mine, where I traced the origins of the idea to post-WWI feeling in Western Europe.
What’s more, what nation is Trump being nationalist about? A casual reader might think it’s the US. But, reading the speech, I can only conclude it’s Poland:
Poland is the geographic heart of Europe, but more importantly, in the Polish people, we see the soul of Europe. Your nation is great because your spirit is great and your spirit is strong.
For two centuries, Poland suffered constant and brutal attacks. But while Poland could be invaded and occupied, and its borders even erased from the map, it could never be erased from history or from your hearts. In those dark days, you have lost your land but you never lost your pride.
So it is with true admiration that I can say today, that from the farms and villages of your countryside to the cathedrals and squares of your great cities, Poland lives, Poland prospers, and Poland prevails.
…You are the proud nation of Copernicus — think of that — Chopin, Saint John Paul II. Poland is a land of great heroes. And you are a people who know the true value of what you defend.
(Chopin, by the way, identified as Polish and considered himself a Polish patriot, but he was actually half-French and spent much of his life in exile from Poland.)
But back to the Guardian:
In a nod to the conservative values [Trump] shares with Poland’s controversial ruling Law and Justice party, Trump also called on the west to defend its traditions…
According to Polish press reports, Trump was enticed to Warsaw by promises of a rapturous reception. The Polish government, which paid for supporters to be bussed in from provincial areas, appeared to have delivered, as the president was greeted by a boisterous, highly partisan, crowd in Krasinski Square, one of Warsaw’s smaller public spaces.
So defending on our traditions in the West—ones we should be justly proud of, such as liberty and democracy—is now controversial and conservative. And the crowd was fake. Got it.
From Trump’s speech:
For America’s part, we have never given up on freedom and independence as the right and destiny of the Polish people, and we never, ever will.
Our two countries share a special bond forged by unique histories and national characters. It’s a fellowship that exists only among people who have fought and bled and died for freedom…
And so I am here today not just to visit an old ally, but to hold it up as an example for others who seek freedom and who wish to summon the courage and the will to defend our civilization.
Trump followed this by a stirring recitation of some of the woes Poland faced in the 20th Century and particularly during WWII, and its bravery against two oppressors, the Nazis and the Soviets, as well as its devotion to religion (particularly, the Pope’s visit in 1979, which helped sparked the drive to freedom from the Soviets).
Trump then segues to:
…another oppressive ideology — one that seeks to export terrorism and extremism all around the globe…
During a historic gathering in Saudi Arabia, I called on the leaders of more than 50 Muslim nations to join together to drive out this menace which threatens all of humanity. We must stand united against these shared enemies to strip them of their territory and their funding, and their networks, and any form of ideological support that they may have. While we will always welcome new citizens who share our values and love our people, our borders will always be closed to terrorism and extremism of any kind.
Hard to argue with that. But it can be done, as Vox’s Sarah Wildman demonstrates in a piece entitled “Trump’s speech in Poland sounded like an alt-right manifesto.” Here’s what she writes:
…[Trump’s speech]…often resorted torhetorical conceits typically used by the European and American alt-right…
In his address, Trump cast the West, including the United States and Europe, on the side of “civilization.” With an undercurrent of bellicosity, he spoke of protecting borders, casting himself as a defender not just of territory but of Western “values.” And, using the phrase he had avoided on his trip to Saudi Arabia, he insisted that in the fight against “radical Islamic terrorism,” the West “will prevail.”…
That battle, the president seemed to say, is ongoing.
And is Wildman saying that the battle is not ongoing, and that to suggest it is in fact ongoing is tantamount to issuing “an alt-right manifesto”? I guess that’s what it’s come to for the anti-Trump press.
Trump also chided Russia, something the MSM articles I read seem to have had some difficulty fully crediting him for, because it doesn’t fit the press narrative. But this is what he said:
We urge Russia to cease its destabilizing activities in Ukraine and elsewhere, and its support for hostile regimes — including Syria and Iran — and to instead join the community of responsible nations in our fight against common enemies and in defense of civilization itself.
Trump also spoke against government bureaucracy, talked about funding NATO, and the history of the Warsaw Uprising. But it was this part of the speech that may have angered the left the most, because of its unapologetic celebration of Western culture (not nationalism, but culturism, if there is such a word):
There is nothing like our community of nations. The world has never known anything like our community of nations.
We write symphonies. We pursue innovation. We celebrate our ancient heroes, embrace our timeless traditions and customs, and always seek to explore and discover brand-new frontiers.
We reward brilliance. We strive for excellence, and cherish inspiring works of art that honor God. We treasure the rule of law and protect the right to free speech and free expression.
We empower women as pillars of our society and of our success. We put faith and family, not government and bureaucracy, at the center of our lives. And we debate everything. We challenge everything. We seek to know everything so that we can better know ourselves.
And above all, we value the dignity of every human life, protect the rights of every person, and share the hope of every soul to live in freedom. That is who we are. Those are the priceless ties that bind us together as nations, as allies, and as a civilization.
Western civilization is what he’s talking about. And those things are indeed things to celebrate and to preserve. If we don’t acknowledge them, how can we defend them?
Just a few short decades ago, when I was growing up, it was standard practice for both parties to talk this way. Now this practice has been taken over almost solely by the right, and sites like Vox (which is not even hard-left, but just garden-variety liberal/left) label it as “alt-right” rhetoric rather than mainstream thought.
And they wonder why they’ve been losing elections lately.