Ted Cruz isn’t perfect and wasn’t perfect even before he made his remarks about the January 6th defendants being “terrorists.” But he’s long been one of the most consistently conservative members of Congress. He’s also unusually smart, and rarely makes an error when he speaks. That’s probably one of the reasons why so many on the right seem unable to forgive him for this statement and are assuming it indicates some nefarious motive on his part.
I’m not one of those people, though. His statement took his standing down a notch in my eyes, but it didn’t invalidate his lengthy record and to me it’s at least plausible that his explanation is true: that he was using a term he’s used for many years to describe people who attack police, no matter what their politics, and by no means did he mean all the January 6th defendants.
Rejection of Cruz for his statement is the sort of thing I’ve come to expect from a lot of people on the right, though. It seems to me to be a zero tolerance policy that sometimes backfires and leads to Democrat victory and some very bad outcomes. I do believe that “the perfect is often the enemy of the good.”
So, what has Cruz previously said on these subjects? I did a bit of research, and here are some statements from Cruz last August about the long-term imprisonment of the January 6th defendants:
Republican Senator Ted Cruz is under fire for arguing that some participants in the Capitol riot should be spared prosecution.
Mr. Cruz told HuffPost that people who “assaulted a police officer” should spend “a long, long time in jail”, but balked at criminal charges for participants who entered the Capitol but did not harm anyone.
Here’s the HuffPost article:
“If, on the other hand, the Biden administration is targeting and persecuting people for exercising political speech that is nonviolent and simply expressing their peaceful support for a political party different from that in power, that is not the purpose of our criminal justice system,” he added.
There’s also this letter from Cruz to Merrick Garland:
In June, Mr Cruz and Senator Tommy Tuberville sent a letter to US Attorney General Merrick Garland complaining that Capitol rioters are facing harsher treatment than people who protested during the George Floyd demonstrations in 2020.
“DOJ’s apparent unwillingness to punish these individuals who allegedly committed crimes during the spring and summer 2020 protests stands in stark contrast to the harsher treatment of the individuals charged in connection with the January 6, 2021 breach of the US Capitol,” the duo wrote.
Also, from the same article (which is very anti-Cruz in the usual manner of the MSM):
Mr Cruz and many of his Republican colleagues have repeatedly tried to downplay the insurrection on 6 January. The senator has a vested interest in doing so, as he led the charge to reject the electoral ballot count the day the riot occurred.
Cruz was one of the main members of Congress defending the challenge to the 2020 election. He also voted against the Jan 6th commission’s establishment.
And what of Cruz’s previous use of the term “terrorist” to describe those who attack police? Well, there’s this from August of 2020 during the BLM/Antifa riots:
‘What you and I don’t have the right to do is to hurt somebody else, to physically assault someone else, to firebomb police cars, to loot and destroy a small business, to murder a police officer and sadly we’ve seen all of that in riots across our country.’
As well as blaming the violence on Antifa, Cruz also laid into Black Lives Matter organizers who he said are ‘pursuing a radical agenda’.
‘These are violent leftists, many of them are anarchists, some of them are affiliated with Antifa the national terrorist organization, some are affiliated with the group called Black Lives Matter which is founded by and is run by open Marxists – people who are calling for a Marxist government in the United States,’ he said.
‘We’re seeing radicals whose objective is what’s going on in Portland every night – they’re assaulting the federal courthouse and trying to burn it down.’…
‘The federal police officers are doing their job of stopping terrorists burning the courthouse to the ground,’ Cruz insisted….
[Many Democrats have made] the very unfortunate political determination that…given the choice between standing with innocent Americans or violent terrorists seeking to hurt their fellow citizens, to date too many of them have stood with terrorists.’
Last March, when Cruz was questioning FBI director Wray, Cruz said this:
In the past year, we have seen massive rioting and violence as extremists, many of them leftist extremists, took to the streets across the country, in just two weeks, at the end of May and early June, over 700 law enforcement officers were injured. Looking at all of 2020, over 14,000 people had been arrested in 49 cities, and at least 25 people have died in the violence. And it’s estimated that the property damages from these riots could exceed $2 billion. What is the FBI doing to counter this ongoing pattern of domestic terrorism?
Also, because Cruz was one of the people heading up the legal procedural challenges to the certification of the electoral votes on January 6th, 2021, as such he drew virulent criticism both before and after the January 6th demonstrations and violence:
U.S. Congressman Joaquin Castro and Texas Democratic Party Chairman Gilberto Hinojosa both said on Wednesday that Cruz should resign…
“I think that’s what it was intended to be: a coup,” he said. “This is an effort by people — who were being encouraged by the President of the United States, and people like Ted Cruz — to take the law into their own hands, and to force the declaration of Donald Trump to be the president of the United States, when he lost the election, when the people in the United States voted by almost 8 million votes to kick him out of office.”
He said Cruz should resign, and the Republican Party should take steps to restore trust in American democracy.
Not that Cruz ever considered resigning, but he probably has extra reason for being angry at the demonstrators/protestors who got out of hand and committed violent acts on January 6th, because he was blamed for it, along with Trump.
I think that, not only did Cruz make an error in calling the January 6th defendants “terrorists,” but I also think that Cruz’s previous remarks defending the non-violent among them haven’t been as strong as I would have liked. But he did defend them previously, and Cruz’s nature has never been to be a firebrand.
My opinion about Cruz even prior to these recent remarks of his is that he never was going to become president. He simply doesn’t have the personality. He’s smart and he can actually be very humorous, but he’s stiff – and the lawyer in him is always in the forefront. Most people don’t warm to him for those reasons, and I think there are better Republican contenders for 2024.
But I’m not turning on him, either; not for this. I think that would be wrong, given his history. He’s been one of the better GOP senators for a long time.