Those who hate Trump on the left and on the erstwhile right also hate the Iran War, or the Iran operation, or whatever you want to call it. They’ve declared it a failure after a month, “without evidence.” Or rather, the evidence they cite is that the regime spokespeople – the ones who are still alive – mouth defiant words and are able to get some missiles off now and then.
And today we have this difficult news:
An American pilot was rescued in a daring operation by US special forces Friday after Iran shot down an F-15E fighter jet — and placed a bounty on the crew.
A second fighter pilot was still missing.
The Iranian Revolutionary Guard Corps claimed “newly developed and advanced air defenses” had downed the jet, which was “completely destroyed and crashed,” Tehran’s Press TV reported.
Since nothing the Iranian press says can be trusted at face value, there’s no reason to imagine this was the result of newly developed or advanced air defenses. If indeed the plane was shot down rather than had some mechanical problem – and I tend to think it was shot down, since the US isn’t denying it (or officially confirming it yet, as far as I can tell). The mechanism probably was either some local air defense system that had remained intact, or had been repaired, or something newly supplied from Russia that actually worked and constituted a surprise.
Trump’s enemies are very happy about this because they can use it to bolster their “the war has failed!” narrative, although there’s no logic to it. Anyone who thought thousands upon thousands of air strikes could occur without one or more planes being shot down (or coming down through mechanical failure) is either tremendously naive or disingenuous or both.
The demand is for no war ever – or if that fails, a perfect war. Even if the current regime were to surrender, I can practically guarantee that the Trump-haters (mostly on the left but not solely on the left) would give him no credit and would say the war was still a failure. They’d find a way and they’d find a reason.
One of the stupidest things they demand is the need to know exactly how long the war will last, even at its outset. Or the need to get a guarantee that everything will work out. Or they pretend that they haven’t been given reasons for the war. They also ignore the differences between the people of Iraq during that war and the Iranian people during this one. In addition, they act as though regime change was the main goal in Iran, and that if it doesn’t happen then the whole endeavor is a failure – when the idea was always that regime change would be an excellent side effect but that destroying the regime’s weapons and leadership would be a vast improvement on the non-war alternatives that have long been the status quo.
But they ignore all that and compare this war to some Platonic perfect war that does not exist in the real world. Or they say, “Of course, it’s a terrible regime that needed to end, but ….” offering no way to have made it end.
Trump is portrayed as stupid and blundering and ill-meaning, because that’s the only Trump that exists in their minds.
What would they have accepted as the proper provocation for a war? For the left, I suppose the answer might be “anything if a Democrat decided on it,” but “nothing” for Trump. And what of the isolationist right? What would they accept? Maybe an actual nuclear attack on the US or a full-scale military invasion by some foreign power? Maybe. Maybe even those things wouldn’t be enough. They might be labeled a false flag, as 9/11 was labeled by 9/11 Truthers who sprang up shortly after that horrific event. Or perhaps this sort of thing:
How long ago did I first start hearing that about FDR and Pearl Harbor? I can’t recall, but it was many decades ago. Even World War II was hardly a perfect war, so that must be discredited as well – a war against one of the most evil enemies in history. And yes, the casualties were very high.
Thing is, once you start feeling that the government has lied to you – which it certainly has at times – some people will slip into the convention that practically everything the government says is a lie – and in particular is a lie if doubting it feeds into their already-existent belief system. Plenty of people have lost faith in anything government says and does, and have found people to blame for that.
Another factor in all of this is the protected nature of most Americans over the years. The draft ended over fifty years ago, and so with an all-volunteer military, most people don’t have to serve in the military and lack any military knowledge of the type that might be learned by serving. I’m not asking to bring the draft back. But an abysmal level of ignorance, and pundits preying on that ignorance, is one of the consequences of the end of the draft.