↓
 
Home » Could this be the most common method for living past 100?

Comments

Could this be the most common method for living past 100? — 17 Comments

  1. I’ve been watching true crime shows recently. One of them featured an elderly pair of black sisters living in Colorado Springs. The case begins with the discovery of one of the sisters wrapped up and mummified on a couch for a number of years. Yes, the living sister was collecting and cashing the two SocSec checks the whole time.

    They had to make sure that there was no evidence that the dead lady had been murdered. They found none. Both sisters were kind of self-styled civil rights champions in their past, and when that ceased to be a paying occupation when they got old, they were desperate for cash.

  2. I’ve seen reports that the stated ages of many living centenarians and “supercentenarians” are also incorrect — but not necessarily because of deliberate fraud. If they’re even close to the ages they’re said to be, they may have been born in a time and place where birth records were poorly kept or disappeared over time.

  3. Panache:

    “… his family claimed he’d shut himself away to become a living Buddha.”

  4. I wonder if this has any impact on Japanese life expectancy data, which is stated to be a few years higher than for the US. Democrats like to use those numbers in their battle for more government-based health care.

  5. It seems to me that governments (ours included) are remiss if they don’t require a “note from your doctor” or some suitable local authority (justice of the peace? county clerk?) annually once you pass a certain age, to be issued only on a personal visual inspection of the living applicant.

    There are enough “social workers” already being paid by the gummint that some of them can be assigned that onerous task.

  6. I’d be skeptical of the claim that 82% of the supposed centenarian population is deceased. Don’t doubt a certain amount of yarn pulling, poor record keeping, and pension fraud, but not to that degree. (There was a woman in France named Jeanne Calment who supposedly lived to be 120 years old; the current thesis about her is that she was actually about 90 when she died and had around 1935 assumed the identity of her mother to avoid estate taxes).

  7. Both sisters were kind of self-styled civil rights champions in their past, and when that ceased to be a paying occupation when they got old, they were desperate for cash.
    ==
    IIRC, they’d both been employees of the U.S. Department of the Interior, but during an era when federal government pensions were fixed and quite modest. (The case was one of Lt. Joe Kenda’s delineated on the Homicide Hunter series).

  8. There is no way on earth the SS Admin can determine if those receiving a check are legit; there are about 70 MILLION recipients of SS checks.

    The SS Admin has to be notified in the event, say, a recipient dies; but what if they are not notified?? What if the recipient is not a citizen?
    Yep, it’s fraud, but the SS Admin – like probably all US govt. agencies – does not have the resources (or willingness??) to determine who should not be receiving a check.

    I will venture a guess – totally unsubstantiated – that at least 10% to 15% of those presently getting SS benefits shouldn’t be.

  9. I will venture a guess – totally unsubstantiated – that at least 10% to 15% of those presently getting SS benefits shouldn’t be.
    ==
    IOW there are 9 million people who’ve died but are receiving Social Security benefits?

  10. JohnTyler @ 11:33am,

    Tech can help immensely here. And has been. There are some great stories on this front mostly being ignored by the MSM and campaigning politicians. Which is a mistake because saving tax payers money is a true, bipartisan issue. Even though the Democrats did a great job of making DOGE a hyper-political issue, I’m hopeful the work done on this front won’t stop, or go away. There is even a non-zero chance this could be the start of something paradigm shifting in U.S. government budget transparency management at the Federal, State and local levels.

    In the specific case of social security fraud for the deceased. My own experience with the bureaucratic component of death in America leads me to believe this is not a major hole in our social security system. In the U.S. in 2026 corpi are mostly delecti, and if there is a corpse involved there are triggers at multiple levels that would make it hard to conceal this information from the social security administration; coroners, death warrants, legal requirements to properly dispose of the body… To avoid this cascade of triggers I think one would have to do what the Japanese sisters did. There have been cases of that in the U.S., but they are few and far between. Highly illegal. Highly risky. And, super unpleasant. Most people don’t want to share their flat with a rotting corpse, no matter the financial upside. I have a good friend who worked on the police force in a major city for decades and calls where an apartment tenant reports a horrendous odor from an apartment that resulted in a rotting corpse weren’t uncommon, but it doesn’t take long for a corpse’s odors to permeate the surroundings.

    However, computer databases and automated processes and algorithms can do great work in rooting out fraud in government expenditures. This is one area where “Minority Report” style algorithms can work, and I don’t think there are any fourth amendment legal issues in using technology for this purpose. The algorithm may point to certain demographics and/or geographic areas where certain frauds are more likely to be found, thus making it cost effective to do hyper-focused audits in those areas. Maybe, statistically, blue eyed members of the Elks lodge who are between the ages of 37 and 39 and live between 40N and 45N degrees of latitude commit fraud around Veterans Administration benefits at a much higher rate than other groups? A computer will find that type of correlation in nano-seconds. Then, have the auditors focus their attention on the Elks in Des Moines and Boise.

    We all saw the work Nick Shirely did in Minneapolis regarding fraud. A computer would have found that out also. Just ask the database what the typical amount of increase in expenditures on daycare for autistic children is? Then ask it to find concentrations of increase 1 or more standard deviations above the mean. Then ask it to look into the database of LLCs formed to provide those services and compare the owners and business addresses.

    We are at a point, technologically, where 95% or more of government fraud can be uncovered fairly easily via technology. It will take conscious, deliberate efforts to keep it from being uncovered.

  11. Compare SS payouts to Medicare records.

    Anyone over 65 getting a SS check but DOESN’T file a Medicare claim for a year is likely dead.

    Who can check? How about the FBI? It would be a good use of their time, as opposed to going to school board meetings, spying on traditional Catholics, and obstructing a legitimately elected President.

  12. Anyone over 65 getting a SS check but DOESN’T file a Medicare claim for a year is likely dead.
    ==
    Good point.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

HTML tags allowed in your comment: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

Web Analytics
↑