↓
 
Home » Another changer heard from – plus, poll of Jewish voters

Comments

Another changer heard from – plus, poll of Jewish voters — 19 Comments

  1. “The poll found that 64 percent of Jewish voters backed Republicans for Congress, while 33 percent supported Democrats”…about that 33% that still support the Democrats–I have some thoughts on the psychological mechanisms that apply here, as well as to many non-Jewish Dem supporters..

    Basically, it’s that the fear of ‘other’ American (working class, non-college, Christian, Trump supporters, rural/Southern people) has been stoked to the point that even creatures like Abdul and Mamdani seem preferable to anything that empowers people in these feared groups.

    See my post The Phobia(s) That Are Destroying America:

    https://davidfoster273133.substack.com/p/the-phobias-that-are-destroying-america

  2. Did non-Orthodox Jews in New York City vote for Mamdani? I mean: did secular (i.e. ethnic and not observant) and Reform Jews vote for Mamdani?

  3. If you see who Roddie Edmonds–Righteous Among The Nations—knew he could trust, all 1300 of them, you’d have a problem fearing The Other (southern, no degree, so forth). Took some serious propaganda there. Irwin Shaw’s short, “Act of Faith” didn’t do it. The truth was out there but…. was overcome. My father’s platoon, Infantry, almost before the smoke of battle cleared, were following the death march treails, picking up the bodies. You think they didn’t Know Things agter the war? What it took to ruin the reputation of such good people is…..

  4. IrishOtter:

    Only 33% of Jews in New York who voted in the mayoral election voted for Mamdani. There is evidence that 81% of NY Jews are NOT Orthodox. Therefore we can conclude that the majority of secular and/or non-Orthodox NY Jews did not vote for Mamdani. However, it’s hard to estimate because turnout in the election was so very low, 34% (general turnout that is; I didn’t see anything on Jewish turnout).

  5. “Only 33%”

    Gotta love it!

    File under: What kind of gefilte fish does Jesus prefer?

  6. I read several of the posts by the changer who “had believed Obama would be a fabulous president,” and thought this one was especially appropriate as a side-bar to Neo’s post. She says that she is black, and very tired of the race hustlers, and angry about how they have poisoned race relations in America. She is eloquent and funny, just as in the post Neo linked.

    However, she never mentions the part Obama played in that poisoning, here or in the post Neo cited (which tbf was focused on the ACA and not his other destructive actions).

    I suspect she is still grieving over how badly he betrayed the hope everyone enthused over before they found out the truth about the changes he had in mind.

    Despite that, she makes the arguments I have been looking to see from “just regular” (not prominent) black Americans for many years, with little success. Until people with her understanding become as active as the race hustlers, we aren’t going to get to where we could have been had the Democrats not spent the last 20 years derailing the train and then burning the engine and cars while they tore up the track.

    https://sensurround.substack.com/p/im-angry

    I have spent most of my life under the apparently mistaken impression that the civil rights movement was about convincing people to stop treating me differently because I am black. This now appears to be an unfashionable position.

    The modern trend seems to be convincing everyone to become extremely aware of race at all times, preferably while yelling.
    …
    [AF: she talks about the trial of Karmelo Anthony and the reaction to it.]
    …
    And then things got genuinely scary. One prominent personality announced: “You don’t want to fuck with black people, because we might fucking kill you.”

    Now, I would like to pause here. Because I am black. And this was extremely useful information for me. I had somehow reached adulthood without realizing I was supposed to be threatening people. This wasn’t in the handbook of “racial behaviors” I was issued at birth. I was under the impression that my responsibilities consisted primarily of paying taxes, worrying about my blood pressure, and trying to remember where I put my car keys. Apparently I have instead been participating in a campaign of racial intimidation without even knowing it.

    This explains why I keep losing my “Black membership” card. The thing that scares me is not that people say this nonsense. America has always produced loud idiots, as it’s one of our great exports.

    What scares me is how many people cheer.

    How many people hear a statement that sounds suspiciously like a threat and decide it is wisdom. How many people hear racial tribalism and mistake it for racial solidarity. Because here’s the ugly truth. Every time one of these people opens their mouth, somebody who has never met me learns something about me. (Or thinks they do.)

    They learn that black people believe violence is justified. They learn that black people reject evidence. They learn that black people only care about race. They learn that black people view justice as a team sport.

    Now, I get to spend my twilight years proving I am not the person they just described. That is what makes me angry.

    Not offended. Not annoyed. Angry.

    See, the Americans in my generation (Gen X and before) worked themselves half to death trying to convince the country that we are individuals.

    Individuals with different opinions. Different politics. Different dreams. Different flaws. But still, regular people. Now a collection of professional race hustlers seems determined to undo all of that so they can collect engagement on social media.
    …

    I don’t want people to fear me. I don’t want people to excuse me. I don’t want people to hate me. I don’t want people to admire me because of my race.

    I want the same thing I have always wanted. I want people to look at me and see a person.

    Not a demographic. Not a historical grievance. Not a political weapon. Not a member of a tribe.

    Just a person.

    Every fucking time some loudmouth gets online and starts screaming “racial identity matters” more than evidence, more than character, more than truth itself, I find myself wondering how many more bridges they’re planning to burn before they run out of matches.

    Judging by the reaction online, the answer appears to be:

    Quite a few.

  7. AesopFan,

    I’ve seen several such people trying to move the black culture, Anthony Daniels and Jeffrey Mead to name two. Yet, given the general attitude in the US, I wonder if these people have any real influence.

    We live in a gated, upscale community where about 40% of the residents are black. And some of them have built, or are building, houses in the $1.5M range: 6000+ sqft, etc. A majority proportion are military vets and entrepreneurs, yet a smaller proportion, the ones building the MacMansions, display the nouveau riche of those still with a ghetto mentality. Ostentation fountains etc on the house; walking around with black hoodies, and true to stereotype, driving Escalades. Also telling is that those black residents who do not display such attitudes are also the ones who are engaged with the community, participate in community projects, and seem to get along quite well with their white neighbors. The MacMansion builders keep to themselves.

  8. It’s quite difficult to generate utile samples of Jewish voters. Even when random-digit dialing could generate probability samples, the confidence intervals around polls of Jewish voters were quite large (+/- 18 %, IIRC).
    ==
    Outside of about four metropolitan centers, Jews are not consequential demographically. What they bring to the table is disposable income, a heightened propensity to make philanthropic donations of all sorts, organizational acumen, and a talent pool in the legal profession and the media. (About 12% of the Democrats in Congress are Jews). It would be quite beneficial to the commonweal in various realms if that talent pool were to take their business (and their human capital) elsewhere.
    ==
    And, looked at dispassionately, they should. The idealistic aspect of mainstream Jewry tends toward investment in causes which remind them of causes current 70 years ago but which are actually quite dissimilar and socially fissiparous. On the practical side, society prospers with an adapted version of what John Rawls called ‘a system of natural liberty’, by which he meant one which respects principles of ‘equal liberty’ and ‘careers-open-to-talents’. Not only does society as a whole prosper with that system, Jews have historically prospered as well. See, for example, the economic advance of pre-war Jewry at a time when no one in this country was doing them any favors.
    ==
    So, let’s hope this is true.

  9. A major problem, as far as I can tell, is that many—astoundingly—believe are under the impression that it’s still the party of FDR (and HST, JFK and LBJ, etc.).

    Go figger…

  10. physicsguy, your neighbors who don’t build the McMansions are probably people like the lady in AesopFan’s excerpt. Like her, I was raised to believe that people are individuals. I don’t see “blacks” or “Jews” but people, whom I may like or dislike depending upon the individuals.

  11. The difficulty Jews have in academia, at least in admissions, due to some version of DEI ought to make some impression, And possibly elsewhere as well. It’s not just a toxic atmosphere for Jewish undergrads as at Harvard, but the discrimination in admissions. And on the outside of academia, or in grad school or med school. Whatever else they see in the dems, this is something they should see and think about. For their own good.
    That a bunch of Jews can get away with a kosher tailgate at Clemson is great. But that they need to go there is the issue.

  12. It’s funny to think that we once believed that the left was the group that favored free speech, opposed censorship, sought to keep universities places where open dialogue was encouraged. Turns out that all they really wanted was to take over and shut their opponents up. Like Erdogan is alleged to have said about democracy being like a train one takes until arrival at one’s station, then steps off. Or as I have said on many occasions: the slave never wants equality with the master; he wants to BE the master.

  13. I have a suspicion that the evolution of black culture and society along with race relations generally would have taken a more salutary path had the larger society
    ==
    (1) devoted heavy effort into seeing to it that public institutions (the police, the courts, and the penal system, the civil service examiners, the voting registrars, &c) operated with professionalism and impartiality,
    ==
    (2) worked to break cartelistic practices in the labor market (and that would have meant serious controls on labor unions),
    ==
    (3) maintained a low minimum wage;
    ==
    (4) limited government subsidized services to medical care, l/t care, schooling, legal services, shipping-and-transportation, and burial expenses;
    ==
    (5) limited cash transfers to the elderly, the authentically disabled, those injured at work, the interstitially unemployed, and low wage workers;
    ==
    (6) invested heavily in law enforcement as the black population left the agricultural economy and migrated to cities (South and north), and transferring responsibility for it to county governments and consortia of counties;
    ==
    (7) disposed of governmental imposition of certain caste practices (military units, categorically segregated school systems, separate water fountains, separate bathrooms &c);
    ==
    (8) limited the discretion of service providers over their custom in certain sectors (services provided by government, utilities, medical care, and services specifically for travelers) but not generally;
    ==
    (9) restructured educational finance, in offerings, and the achievement milestones in primary and secondary and tertiary schoolings (in particular offering more vocational technical instruction);
    ==
    (10) Eschewed public finance of non-profits except in discrete circumstances, limited the lawful activity of foundations to providing finance of a certain classes of non-profit service providers, and required foundations to liquidate within 60 years of their incorporation.
    ==
    (11) distributed broadcast licenses to proprietorships, partnerships, and limited corporations operated by people domiciled in the geographic broadcast area in question, did so via sexennial auctions, and limited content regulation to the quantum of advertising per half-hour and the hours of the day in which blue material could be broadcast.
    ==
    (12) taken to biennial assessments of real property in all jurisdictions and radically reduced or eliminated levies on slum property.
    ==
    (13) eschewed rent control and eschewed rococo procedures to implement evictions.
    ==
    (14) eschewed land use regulations (generally or in core cities) which tended to suppress the emergence and maintenance of certain housing types (emergency shelters, flop houses, SRO hotels, boarding houses, apartments with shared kitchens..).

  14. Dear Mr. Deco:
    I congratulate you on your thorough deconstruction of all that is wrong with contemporry America. You are quite correct in your analysis. I submit, however, that we could have arrived at the same solutions you propose by following the example of The Honorable Davey Crockett, who declined to support a congressional grant of a stipend to a deserving military widow on the basis that there was simply no sanction for such actions to be found in our Constitution. He did, however, offer to donate a week’s salary as a Congressman to her aid.

  15. I submit, however, that we could have arrived at the same solutions you propose by following the example of The Honorable Davey Crockett, who declined to support a congressional grant of a stipend to a deserving military widow on the basis that there was simply no sanction for such actions to be found in our Constitution. He did, however, offer to donate a week’s salary as a Congressman to her aid.
    ==
    You and Wm. Voegeli are free to amuse yourselves debating the political controversies of the 1790s. We just need to know whether Congress has the authority to build post roads or may merely designate existing roads as post roads.
    ==
    And, when you’re done with that, the two of you can have a discussion of what is meant by the terms ‘fringe benefit’ and ‘deferred compensation’.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

HTML tags allowed in your comment: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

Web Analytics
↑