I’ve read a wide variety of analyses of the results, from “it’s really a plus-ten-point GOP district, so this is exactly as expected” to “the Republican should have done a lot better and this is a wake-up call.”
Roger L. Simon – who’s been living near Nashville for quite a few years now – has this to say:
What does this mean? Not a lot. I would define it as “Much Ado About Nothing… Much.”
That, of course, will not stop the thumb suckers who already have their thumbs out and are ready to point blame. I predict two explanations:
One, typical Republican voter passivity, especially without Trump running.
Two, changed demographics. All those domestic p/p[ gtvyf migrants who have been moving from blue states to red states to escape state income tax have brought their blue state values with them.
While there might be some elements of truth here, I reject both of these overall.’
Regarding the passivity, it’s not the voters who are passive so much as the Republican leadership, starting at the top. This is true of several red states, but definitely of Tennessee. (Neighboring Georgia is worse.) The local GOP, with a few exceptions, never got in gear to seriously win this election against the target-rich Behn until the last couple of weeks. The Democrats had been going full tilt for a long while. Don’t blame the GOP voters.
Simon goes on to add that the newcomers are mostly conservatives.
His explanation – passive and complacent leadership – dovetails with what I wrote in yesterday’s post: “Behn got a head start in early votes that probably occurred before the GOP was alerted to the danger of an upset.”
I’ve also read that Nashville is now populated by quite a few of those young “we wuz robbed” type voters who voted in NYC for Mamdani’s promises of “affordability”:
Not unlike NYC, Nashville is now filled with both 20somethings who really cannot afford to live there and are susceptible to all this affordability nonsense and blue state migrants who are gonna import their politics. Both are more highly motivated to vote in these special elections. As for the former: elite overproduction is a thing. Lots of these 25 yo folks who hit all the marks and got their NYU degree are pissed when they look around and see some dude who went to Alabama or Tennessee and studied accounting or see trades people earning more than they are tending bar. Then I think their impulse is to go into politics and figure out how to expropriate it.
Well, Roger Simon rejects the “blue state migrants” explanation. But I think that the “angry, entitled 20-somethings who know nothing about socialism” explanation may well be correct. Watch out for that demographic.
