Home » The significance of the Virginia redistricting vote

Comments

The significance of the Virginia redistricting vote — 14 Comments

  1. It seems the main issue is the way the proposal was worded on the ballot, “restoring fairness,” as opposed to accurately saying what a yes or no vote be for or against. I think this will be part of the legal battle, though odds are against getting an impartial judge.

  2. Ballot wording is an artform for Democrats and others who want to control elections, most often IMO when money is involved, regardless of “political” ideology. We recently had a referendum on zoning, and to defeat the proposed changes we had to vote “YES” because of the way the choice was worded.

    Not the first time that has happened in Colorado.

  3. Appeal to any historical precedent you want, we are watching a horror rise before our very eyes. And while there is no direct precedent for what’s happening, history is indeed rhyming. I believe we’re seeing a soft, slow motion echo of the Russian revolution, different in many respects because of differences in law, institutions, culture, and technology, but an echo nonetheless. As the revolution is being mounted by elites and power hungry thugs who have repudiated the values of the society and are willing to push extra-legal action without limit, the normal tools available to thoughtful and reasonable people will be unavailing. Our only hope is for a massive outpouring of public protest, something unprecedented in this country.

  4. Beat me to it, Mike Plaiss. The allegation, which this judgment affirms, is that the legislature did not follow legally required timing for scheduling this special election, and that it failed to publish the amendment wording three months before the election, as required by law.

    It will be appealed, of course.

  5. There’s not much to be done against a numerical majority of a state, no matter how geographically concentrated. It’s great that a court has apparently already said it violates the Virginia constitution, but the Virginia legislature can amend their constitution with a simple majority of both houses, and guess who elects those people?

    If it’s delayed long enough they may give up of course.

  6. the Virginia legislature can amend their constitution with a simple majority of both houses

    Why even bother having a constitution?

  7. @Mike Plaiss:Why even bother having a constitution?

    You got me. California’s is one of the longest in the world and contains highly specific clauses such as

    Except for tax exemptions provided in Article XIII, the rights, powers, privileges, and confirmations conferred by Sections 10 and 15 of Article IX in effect on January 1, 1973, relating to Stanford University and the Huntington Library and Art Gallery, are continued in effect.

    because it can be amended by initiatives which can be passed by majority vote. The Constitution of California is practically “Simon Says”.

  8. Paging CC™-R.

    You have some crow to catch and consume, although Corvids are very intelligent, so that may explain why you still haven’t eaten all that you’ve pledged.

    The Democrats in VA hold their serfs in utter contempt it seems, wasting everyone’s time with such a flawed process. Ends and means I guess. For the party and the greater good! (sarc x 11)

  9. When the Dems take Congress and the presidency…It will be a bloodless coup d’etat, because the constitution will be totally ignored as a result of the packing of the SCOTUS…” JohnTyler

    “So much of left-wing thought is a kind of playing with fire, by people who don’t even know that fire is hot,” George Orwell

    What the left fails to grasp is that for millions of Americans, liberty is not ‘an option’. They fail to grasp on both an intellectual and emotional level that many of those millions resonate with Jefferson’s declaration that, “When tyranny becomes law, rebellion becomes duty” There are millions upon millions of us veterans who still take seriously our oath to defend the Constitution from all enemies, foreign and domestic. Many of those veterans are combat vets, and many of them were trained in counter insurgency warfare. Quite a few understand that while tactics win battles, logistics wins wars.
    Those who vote left are overwhelmingly concentrated in urban and suburban areas. Into which all water, food, energy and medicine must be imported. The supply chains of which can be easily disrupted. So no need for pitched battles, just 3 days of food resides in grocery stores…

    “There is a way which seemeth right unto a man, but the end thereof are the ways of death” Proverbs 14:12

  10. I’m trying to catch up on the redistricting/gerrymandering issues in order to have an informed opinion. Still not there but …

    Some of the current confusion comes from the Voting Rights Act (1965) which required racial redistricting (gerrymandering) to prevent Southern Democrats from gerrymandering districts so blacks could never win at the district level and thus have little say at the state level.

    This is the “voter dilution” problem. However, it’s rather like anti-racism requiring racism as a solution.

    It’s a right mess. Which isn’t to say Democrats and Republicans are equally to blame, but legal argumentation is muddy.

  11. Population centers control the vote, as is the case here in Colorado. AP, wait until the ballot comes out this year!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

HTML tags allowed in your comment: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

Web Analytics