From T. S. Eliot’s poem The Hollow Men:
In this last of meeting places
We grope together
And avoid speech
Gathered on this beach of the tumid river…
This is the way the world ends
This is the way the world ends
This is the way the world ends
Not with a bang but a whimper.
At first the shutdown seemed somewhat reasonable although extreme, given the predictions from epidemiologists and the news we had seen coming from China and then Italy. “Flatten the curve” and keep the health care system from being overwhelmed seemed important goals.
They were met. And yet still we see some governors continue their little dictatorships, making seemingly arbitrary pronouncements that continue to infringe on people’s rights as the situation seems to become less and less full of peril in terms of public health.
Yes, the danger exists, and more people are going to die. That’s always true, and it may indeed be more true than usual right now. But people need to live while they’re living, and unless there is an utterly compelling reason for a restriction it needs to go.
Citizens have been fairly cooperative so far. That’s either a good thing or a bad thing, depending on how you look at it. It’s “good” if you think it’s necessary to comply with orders that restrict people’s rights for a while, because the danger remains overwhelmingly great. It’s “bad” if you think this is sheepish slavish nonsense, a testing of the waters for greater tyranny, and quite unnecessary as well.
But the natives are getting restless – even in California, albeit in the redder parts of that blue blue state. There has been protesting and defiance in Sacramento and Huntington Beach:
…[T]he California governor has been less than candid in sharing a timeline of reopening with Californians. And, in an obvious instance of political pique, he shut down Orange County beaches because visitors supposedly failed to follow social distancing guidelines.
Huntington Beach is one of those Orange County locations. On Friday thousands flocked to those shores to protest the needless closures.
“Large crowds opposing the state’s coronavirus stay-at-home mandate took to the streets of downtown Huntington Beach on Friday, a day after the governor closed Orange County beaches and drew frustration and criticism from some residents and city leaders.
“Protesters gathered near the Huntington Beach pier shortly before noon, with the crowd eventually swelling to some 2,500-3,000 people, according to Huntington Beach police Chief Robert Handy. The tightly packed crowd, with most people not wearing protective masks, repeatedly chanted “U.S.A.” as they waited for the demonstration to begin.”
California isn’t the only place this is happening. People want their lives back, and they are willing to assume the risk. Others, who consider themselves to be among the more at risk, can continue to stay home and isolate if they like. But normal-ish life needs to resume for those less at risk.
But how many people feel this way compared to those who want the restrictions to go on and on and on, till COVID is completely vanquished? No doubt it varies from state to state. One thing that’s clear is that a lot of people in South Dakota are happy their state was never really closed down at all:
Republican South Dakota Governor Kristi Noem had an impromptu parade thrown in her honor on Tuesday in the capitol city of Pierre. A local construction company organized the parade to show appreciation for her handling of the coronavirus epidemic.
Noem, the state’s first female governor, was one of a handful of governors not to issue an order shuttering non-essential businesses during the ongoing epidemic.
The parade, organized by John Morris of Morris Inc. construction company, featured “literally hundreds of cars,” fire trucks and other vehicles honking their horns and sirens while Noem watched, apparently surprised, from a local park.
Of course, it helps that South Dakota has barely had any COVID at all: a total of 21 deaths. That’s in a state that with a population that’s somewhere in the 800 thousands, and a low population density as well. But still, it took courage for Governor Noem to hold back in the face of tremendous criticism. Her gamble paid off.
The COVID crisis has many elements, but one of them is that it’s a test of how important liberty is to the American people. How most Americans will answer that test is still being sorted out.
[ADDENDUM: At first I thought this article was satire. Apparently it’s not. At least, I don’t think it is.]