Afghanistan has long been a terrible place to go to war, as Kipling knew:
When you’re wounded and left on Afghanistan’s plains,
And the women come out to cut up what remains,
Jest roll to your rifle and blow out your brains
An’ go to your Gawd like a soldier.
So now we’re getting out of Afghanistan. Some commentary from Mike Rogers, House member:
For months, I have pressed President Biden for a plan to avoid the very situation that is now happening in Afghanistan. Now, American lives are at risk because President Biden still doesn’t have a plan. Weeks ago, President Biden promised the American people that we would not have a Saigon moment in Afghanistan – Now, we are watching President Biden’s Saigon moment unfold before us.
“The turmoil happening in Afghanistan is a surprise to no one. Unfortunately, I believe the worst is yet to come.
“Our allies are watching as Afghanistan rapidly deteriorates and President Biden still claims he does not regret his unconditional withdrawal. Make no mistake, the consequences of President Biden’s haphazard withdrawal will be felt for decades.
Among other things, I think the way this is playing out is a sign that the military has become confused and incompetent.
“The latest U.S. military intelligence assessment suggests Kabul could come under insurgent pressure within 30 days and that, if current trends hold, the Taliban could gain full control of the country within a few months,” the Associated Press reported on Thursday…
The Taliban captured a strategic provincial capital near Kabul on Thursday, the 10th the insurgents have taken in a weeklong sweep across Afghanistan just weeks before the end of the American military mission there.
…[A] resurgent Taliban estimated to now hold some two-thirds of the nation, and thousands of people have fled their homes…
I have read that they now have 17 capitals, and counting.
There’s no dearth of opinions on this, so I’ll add mine. I trust that the Biden administration and the current “woke” military will do this in an incompetent way.
As for what should have been done in the first place, I thought then and I still think now that we were between a rock and a hard place. Afghanistan was harboring Bin Laden, al Qaeda, and large training camps for terrorists. We gave the government at the time (the Taliban, that is) an ultimatum: surrender Bin Laden or we’ll go to war. They didn’t, and we did. We took over the country in a military sense, but what should we have done then?
Afghanistan is recalcitrant to change. Nation-building there has always been an iffy proposition, to say the least. But it always seemed to me that if we were going to make that gamble, we needed to be prepared to pretty much take over the country for a long long time. If we lacked the will to take over for the long haul, then it was a waste to have attempted it.
We did lack that will and that commitment, and yet we did attempt it. So it was almost certainly doomed to failure.
And yet could we have kept some troops there just to fulfill our original goal, which was to discourage the setting up of major terrorist operations there? I don’t have the answer, but I think that was the only reasonable solution at this point. As commenter “TJ” wrote today:
Afghanistan will remain the base for renewed Islamist terror mayhem. The costs of attempting this project in an urban area are now way too low for them not to work towards this aim and the money supporting it too much and too available for it not to go on again…
I don’t like this at all. But there it remains – a threat wielded by Islamic zealots. Against the US and the world
I don’t know whether the prognosis is as bad as TJ states. But I do know that it is a distinct possibility, and that it is the reason we went there in the first place. When people say nothing was accomplished in the Afghan war and all the occupation years after that, I believe they are forgetting that it may have discouraged many more terrorist attacks, and particularly well-organized ones (such as 9/11) at that.
I don’t think the Biden administration has a clue how to manage the fallout. Biden himself certainly doesn’t and I wouldn’t have expected him to have known what to do even if he were still in full possession of his wits. And the generals? There’s this:
???
"For the last seven months I've watched Generals engage in twitter fights with people, debate the merits of Critical Race Theory on Capital Hill. It seemed like our generals were more concerned with fighting Tucker Carlson than they were the Taliban" – @SeanParnellUSA pic.twitter.com/7dwzBj6A2c
— Donald Trump Jr. (@DonaldJTrumpJr) August 13, 2021
That is by design, not by accident. The priority of the Obama administration regarding military personnel was cooperation with the leftist political agenda, and Trump was unable to reverse that.
[NOTE: The parallels with Vietnam are obvious, although hardly exact. But I’m going to link to one of my previous posts about the way our involvement in South Vietnam ended.]
