And yet here we are.
In some ways it’s better than it was then. For example, the US isn’t actively at war abroad, and young people aren’t subject to the draft to fight in such a war. But in so very many ways it’s worse. The protesting students these days are far more likely to be ignorant and far more motivated by hatred (which is not to say there weren’t ignorant or hateful students back then). The students these days are far more likely to be highly organized and directed (which is not to say there wasn’t such organization and direction back then). And the authorities these days are even more likely to cave in to the students, many of whom are not even students (which isn’t to say there weren’t “outside agitators” back then and plenty of caving by administrations; see all my posts on Cornell in 1969).
I have no nostalgia for the 60s. I was young, and I guess that was nice. I certainly looked better. But the decade seemed to me to be another “low dishonest decade,” although the present time seems lower and even more dishonest. Then again, I wasn’t around in 1939, the decade in which the poem I just linked was written. It was awful, too, although for different reasons.
If you read the news – and just about everybody here does – you can easily see that the current pro-Palestinian and anti-Zionist and anti-Semitic demonstrations are occurring at many many universities and cities, and seem very well-supplied and orchestrated. Authorities differ in their responses depending on their own politics. Ace has several good posts on this; please see this, this, and this, among others.
Last night I was looking at comments at Gerard’s blog, and a commenter there mentioned this post Gerard wrote about the Berkeley riots for the “People’s Park”, and the reaction to them, occurring way back in 1969. Gerard was there at the time, and his piece is entitled “Regarding My ‘Walk-On Part in the War.'” I think it’s well worth reading for “compare and contrast” reasons. Among other things, the Berkeley students and the “outside agitators” weren’t spouting anti-Semitic hatred. Among others, they were up against Ronald Reagan. And something I had forgotten – if I even knew it at the time – was that the police fired buckshot at the students and one student, observing from a roof, was killed by the buckshot. An excerpt from Gerard’s essay:
First, you had the Highway Patrol showing up who were not as gentle as the Berkeley Police. Then you had the Oakland Cops showing up. “Gentle” was not in their instruction manual. Instead, their first move was to open their trunks and take out their street-sweeping shotguns. Then they racked them and opened fire.
This resulted in a lot of loose buckshot wounds with one person blinded for life, and one person killed outright. (James Rector. I remember his name today after fifty years because he was shot on the roof right above me as I was running away from the shotguns at speed.)
I suggest you read the whole thing. It includes many photos, as well as a short news video with a brief cameo appearance by none other than the young (I believe shirtless, if I’m not mistaken) Gerard Vanderleun.