Home » Roundup

Comments

Roundup — 7 Comments

  1. Diogenes famously went looking for an honest man. How about someone with basic integrity? Does such a man (or woman) even exist? Does anyone care? Or perhaps of greater interest, was integrity more valued in the past, or do we all suffer from a filtered vision of the past? Does modern technology merely provide a bigger firehose for the mendacity that suffuses all (or most) of us?

  2. (4) WOW!!! Gotta love Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu — ‘I’m going to speak the truth in front of this hate-spewing elected official..‘ Great man and great leader…

  3. Ho hum. Beginning with Walter Duranty, maybe even earlier, there has been no shortage of communist sympathizers and fellow travelers in the American media.

  4. It depends on how much of the text was plagiarized and whether or not it was done intentionally. Alex Haley was found civilly liable for plagiarizing the work of the historian Harold Courlander. IIRC, the scattered Courlander passages might have amounted in sum to < 1% of the text in Haley's book. Haley was not a man of Kantian discipline and the book was (per his 3d wife) composed by the two of them in an eighteen month marathon of writing. She said it was a disorganized mass of research material when they started on the project.
    ==
    OTOH, critics who have read Martin Luther King's doctoral thesis have calculated that about 1/3 the text was a paraphrase of work by Paul Tillich and the dissertation of an earlier student at BU named John Boozer. (DK if this is the correct proportion or not). Dissertations have long been indexed by Dissertation Abstracts International and it has been true for decades that any researcher with borrowing privileges at a college or university library could order a microfilm copy of a dissertation via University Microfilms International (which later produced printed copies for requestors). King emerged as a prominent figure in 1955. It was another 35 years before someone actually read his dissertation, recognized his inspirations, and wrote critically about it. You’d think this country’s theology faculties would have more curiosity than that.

  5. I suppose its banal to point out that when educational administrators, corporation executives, public sector executives, and faculty want blacks as decorative items, you’re going to have issues you would not otherwise have from removing selective screens which would otherwise be in place. One of them is the mismatch between the subject and the institution employing him. So, you had Melissa Harris at Princeton when she might have been a satisfactory fit for one of New Jersey’s state colleges, &c. The subject’s time is wasted as is everyone else’s.

  6. At my environmental law professor’s in class hint about researching each state’s geothermal laws, I wound up doing that for my JD paper. He didn’t acknowledge me in his paper, but I did get an “A” for the class. So I’m satisfied.

    And the states’ geothermal energy laws are a hodgepodge.

  7. Some of the passages in the Cambridge professor’s writing aren’t just taken word-for-word from other scholars’ work, but even contain the same unique spelling and grammar errors.

    In other words, he didn’t just (allegedly) plagiarize — that seems to happen all the time in academia — but he plagiarized badly.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

HTML tags allowed in your comment: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

Web Analytics