Advice for young men: can they protect themselves from false allegations?
Commenter “William Klein” has some advice for young men, on the Cornell rape accuser thread:
College men need to completely stay away from women. Study, go to football games, develop lasting friends with other men. But don’t risk you entire future massing around with females. After school also avoid women at work. The best strategy – wait till after education and find a girl at church.
I have no doubt there’s a subset of young men already doing that. It’s not easy, of course, especially at that age. That doesn’t mean it can’t be done, but there are mainly two groups of young men abstaining at present. The first is the group to which I assume Bill Klein is referring: the devout. Their motive is probably only tangentially to avoid false accusations. Instead, it’s to follow the precepts of chastity until marriage and fidelity within it. This group is significant, but the approach isn’t going to be followed by most people these days, and I don’t see that changing.
The second group is more pointedly responding to both the risk of false allegations and the risk of relationships with women in general, plus the availability of porn and other (shall we call them “self-help”) ways of dealing with the young men’s own sexual drive. They basically hate and distrust women, and at this point figure they can get their own needs met without interacting with actual women in the real world. This is a group that appears to be growing, and it’s affecting the marriage rate and the birth rate, because once such distrust takes hold it can be difficult to reverse course and easier to avoid the messy business of actual relationships with actual people.
Plus, I don’t think there’s any way to completely protect oneself against false allegations of sexual misconduct. Any interaction at all can be lied about. If the legal system relies on “he said she said” claims and doesn’t require much if any proof, falsely accused men are in deep deep trouble.
When I was growing up, sexual mores were different and there was a lot less fooling around before marriage. But there was still plenty. One difference was that there was a lot less birth control; another was that resulting teen pregnancies were often dealt with through marriage. According to a chart here (#2, and although it only goes up to the 1990s it’s the earlier years I’m talking about anyway):
The total proportion of first births which were either premaritally born or premaritally conceived to women 15 to 19 years old increased from 28 percent in the early 1930s to 89 percent in the early 1990s (Table 2). The proportion of premaritally conceived teen births which occurred within marriage peaked at about 59 percent in 1960-64. By 1990-94, only 16 percent of premaritally pregnant teen women married before their first birth.
Twenty-eight percent isn’t nothing, although it pales in comparison to today. But it does indicate at least a fair amount of teenage fooling around back then.
Another difference was that false accusations by women were less successful for the accusers in terms of legal redress back then. There still were false accusations; no doubt about that, and some of the men were wrongly convicted. But “believe all women” was not a thing at all.
The distrust of women among young men today is unsurprising. The recent Cornell accusations have joined a long list of previous accusations that have turned out to have been false or iffy. These days, they tend to take the form of consent seemingly given by the women and then later retracted, ex post facto.
I’ve written on this subject before. Please see this piece, this one, and especially this post of mine. From the latter:
Fast forward to now, and the effort by school administrators, egged on by the Obama administration and politically correct thinking, to put new rules of behavior into place for how the sexes ought to relate to each other now that the old rules are a distant memory. Discussions of a supposed campus “rape culture” and what to do about it—including whether it actually exists and what constitutes an objectionable sexual assault—are legion.
One way to conceptualize the whole thing is with an analogy to an endoskeleton versus an exoskeleton, an inner support structure versus an outer one. When I was in school we had both: the university rules were the exoskeleton, and our own personal rules for behavior were an endoskeleton. When the campus rules got jettisoned so precipitously at the same time the sexual revolution was happening, the whole thing turned to a sea of endoplasm for young people of the time, who were left without much guidance, either internal or external, for their sexual behavior. Some people (the religious, for example) retained their previous internal standards as well as the external ones provided by their religious subgroups. But many of the rest became lost, although they probably would not have described it that way—they would have described it as “free.”
But other problems crept in. Morning-after guilt. Women feeling pressured to have more sex than they were comfortable with, either by mores or by men or by their own idea of what their own sexiness should be. Men feeling pressured in other ways, including the perception that they weren’t getting as much sex as other men. Confused communication, misunderstandings.
In recent years all of this has led universities to institute a new exoskeleton, a set of guidelines that are somewhat different than they used to be but that attempt to make explicit the restrictions within the generalized freedom: for example, “yes means yes” laws, rampant “rape culture” fears, and the burgeoning practice of judging men’s behavior without traditional due process protections.
As commenter “mizpants” put it, some of this is a “reaction to the vulnerability of women after the breakdown of traditional social constraints on sexuality.” And it ends up making men more vulnerable, too, particularly to false accusations.
Can we put Humpty Dumpty back together again?

A little imagination leads to a world where a safe outlet for male sexual desire is not only sex robots for the physical side but SI enabled for the intellectual aide. A companion who really is reliable, puts out, and who will never turn on you.
A little more imagination leads to thirty something women yearning for motherhood organizing themselves as sister wives with a high quality male shared among them.
Humans are heading into unknown territory
Answer to your question: no.
“Can we put Humpty Dumpty back together again?”
Not before artificial wombs are created, but your question will be moot by then.
Clarification of answer to the first question, can young men protect themselves?
Answer is still: no.
If we’re not careful the effort to put the sexual revolution back into the bottle will be in Islamic form, not what we had in our childhoods.
Friendship without “benefits”. And courtship with presumptive fidelity. Invest with a fiduciary responsibility.
Vive la sexual revolution! Maybe, baby, maybe not. #NoKinks
Just saw a video today with a guy on first date and girl pulls out a drink cover. He asks her, do you not trust me? She says, it’s just for my own protection. He rightly gets up and leaves.
physicsguy:
Date rape drugs are a real risk, although they’re certainly not common. But more importantly, you say this was a FIRST date. Unless she’s known him for a while in some other context, why would she trust him? Especially if they initially met at a computer dating site, which is increasingly common. Trust needs to be earned in that sort of situation.
Her being that degree of paranoid is somewhat of a red flag. Him demanding immediate trust is also a red flag IMHO.