The middle-aged Aled Jones sings a duet with the young Aled Jones
I sent this video to a friend of mine and he commented, “I hear a brilliant treble singing with an okay but nothing-special baritone.”
And I basically agree. But I think it’s almost unbearably poignant to hear the two versions of Jones singing together, and to watch the old clips together with the new. Don’t their (his??) voices blend beautifully?
[NOTE: I’ve written about Aled Jones before, and the wonderful documentary made about him when he was a young pre-pubescent teenager.]
Oh my goodness, his voice(s) connect directly to my tears.
Adult voice sounds like a tenor to me, not baritone. And, perfectly pleasant. It’s hard to tell how good the adult voice is because he harmonizes and lets the young voice handle the pyrotechnics – but, maybe that choice is telling in itself.
That was beautiful Neo, thank you. I agree with Judith, the adult voice was definitely a tenor.
Wonderful! When my boys were small they had a video tape called “The Snowman”, about a flying snowman. I’d swear that this was the music for it.
Yep! Watch the animation. It always made me smile and still does.
https://youtu.be/ubeVUnGQOIk
Definitely a tenor, not a baritone. Ray Price has a baritone, https://youtu.be/nVNOsWB-Z88
A tenor and a baritone. https://youtu.be/5PYt2HlBuyI
Very sweet. It recalls the moment my soprano voice failed mid-solo and how crushed I was. How I wish I had stuck with singing and used those early years experience to help develop my sudden baritoneness.
And then, as so often these last almost 50 years, I chuckle and thank God for my war time in the third world that put such complaints into perspective.
Boy/soprano adult/baritone
Lovely
Aaack!
2d try
boy/soprano adult/TENOR
NOT baritone
To all:
Hate to be picky—but from Wiki (hey, that rhymes!) [emphasis mine]i:
However, I’m certainly no expert on the tenor vs. baritone subject. He may be able to sing in both ranges, but is somehow considered a baritone.
From the Guardian [emphasis mine]:
Bah on the Guardian.
We say here that’s tenor, so we have decided.
My favorite tenor https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xN-JCdM4or0
My favorite baritone https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aHhwOByP81I
Either way it’s great that he was able to train up from his chidhood voice
While at it, favorite tenor & favorite baritone at it https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xmKUZeJB_Nw
Thank you for sharing this lovely, haunting piece of music…which nearly brings me to tears at its beauty. I had not known before of Aled Jones nor of “The Snowman.” What a wonderful discovery!
I remember hearing the treble version accompanying The Snowman when I was young. It met my criteria for great music — a shiver down my spine. This version is beautiful and very poignant.
My wife loves this song — I didn’t know it.
I did love Mark Lester in Oliver in ’68 — but now I read that it wasn’t his voice, it was the daughter of the music arranger.
Plus, Mark might be the sperm donor father of … Michael Jackson’s daughter Paris.
So much to read.
Lovely song; and original too (thx @Paul)
I have a recording of Aled Jones (the boy) singing Pie Jesu in Faure’s requiem. It’s ok, but I really do think it sounds better with a female voice. There was something about the timbre (perhaps it’s true for all boy sopranos) which just didn’t seem to me to fit the part in this particular piece.
To respond to Fausta, I don’t really have a favourite tenor or baritone (or even bass), but I do like Siegfried Jerusalem, and Bernd Weikl, both of whom were fine Wagnerians.
Llwddythlw, yes to SJ and Bernd! I especially like Bernd’s speaking voice https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nk0_SKdm2k4