Ann Althouse notes that Walter Russell Mead has closed comments on his blog with the following explanation:
To make the comments section work in its present form we would have to edit and curate much more aggressively than we do now and in our current judgment the effort needed to do that is better spent improving other features of the blog.
Althouse writes:
The previous post [at Mead’s blog], the last post with comments, is saying that the blog hit a new traffic record. That got 11 comments. 11 comments! Is it really that hard to “edit and curate”?
Going to Mead’s blog, I notice he adds that in three years of blogging he’s gotten 40,000 comments. That’s a fair number, about 13,333 a year, which made me realize I have absolutely no idea have many comments I’ve gotten here. Since WordPress obligingly keep count, I took a look: 166,490 and counting.
Let’s see. I’ve been blogging for about 7 1/2 years, which makes approximately 22,200 comments a year. Is it particularly arduous to “edit and curate” those comments? No, it’s really not; I’m with Althouse on this.
I’m only one person here. On my old blog, using Blogger, policing comments was difficult, I admit. But with my move to WordPress I gained a ton of much more effective tools to fight the trolls and spammers. It doesn’t take all that much time or effort, either—and much more importantly, the gains from allowing a comments section are vast.
Mead is a well-known writer in print journalism rather than primarily a blogger, so my guess is that he became used to writing without comments long before he enabled them. It would make sense that he can take them or leave them. But I learned quite some time ago that, although I’ve written articles at sites that don’t have comments, I much much MUCH prefer the immediate feedback and the camaraderie of a comments section.
In fact, I very much doubt I would blog without them. It would be like dropping a stone down a well and watching it disappear.