Lady Justice takes her blindfold off
The traditional statue of justice conveys the idea of impartiality and fairness:

That’s the goal although of course it’s very imperfectly realized. The rules governing the legal system – the adversary system as a whole, the fact that everyone is entitled to representation, a jury of your peers, innocent till proven guilty, no double jeopardy – are geared to fostering impartiality and fairness is assumed to be aligned with impartiality although it is also understood that the goal is impossible to reach. But it’s a goal for which to strive.
Social justice warriors on the left – and note the use of that term “justice” – have decided that the system is so poor at leading to true justice that it must be changed, subverted, or jettisoned entirely, and that one way to do that is by policy changes put into practice by people in power. Judges are there to bend the laws and help them “evolve” even if the legislature is slow to do so. Lawyers defending people on the right – the evil people, that is – must be intimidated so that the bad people can’t get representation by anyone competent. As for criminals, if they’re poor and/or members of a designated victim class, they should be let off the hook.
The whole idea of adversary proceedings, whether in courtrooms or in debate, is under attack….why allow Bad People to have any representation at all?
The idea is the exact opposite of the traditional one conveyed in the statues with the blindfold and the scale. Justice can only be meted out when the blindfold is off and Justice can see the defendant and know what’s relevant: class, sex, race, religion, and political affiliation. Once that is known, the scale can be recalibrated to favor those the left feel are good and penalize those who are bad.
Only in that way can social justice start to be implemented, according to the left. A better word for social justice, and one that the more idealistic people on the left (and there still are idealistic people on the left; I know quite a few people I’d describe that way) think they are aiming for would be the phrase used by Thomas Sowell in his fine book The Quest For Cosmic Justice, a book I highly recommend. As usual, Sowell’s description is both clear and succinct:
Cosmic justice is not simply a higher degree of traditional justice, it is a fundamentally different concept. Traditionally, justice or injustice is characteristic of a process. A defendant in a criminal case would be said to have received justice if the trial were conducted as it should be, under fair rules and with the judge and jury being impartial. After such a trial, it could be said that “justice was done” – regardless of whether the outcome was an acquittal or an execution. Conversely, it the trial were conducted in violation of the rules and with a judge or jury showing prejudice against the defendant, this would be considered an unfair or unjust trial – even if the prosecution failed to the end to get enough jurors to vote to convict an innocent person. In short, traditional justice is about impartial processes rather than either results or prospects. …
What “social justice” seeis to do is to eliminate undeserved disadvantages for selected groups. … [T]his is often done in disregard of the costs of this to other individuals or groups – or even to the requirements of society as a whole. …
In its pursuit of justice for a segment of society, in disregard of the consequences for society as a whole, what is called “social justice” might more accurately be called anti-social justice, since what consistently gets ignored or dismissed are precisely the costs to society. Such a conception of justice seeks to correct, not only biased or discriminatory acts by individuals or by social institutions, but unmerited disadvantages in general, from whatever source they may arise.
There’s much much more in Sowell’s book, of course. He goes on to further examine what he calls “cosmic justice,” which purports to seek to rectify all “unmerited disadvantages.” This will of course end up doing no such thing, but that doesn’t stop the quest.
That quest is in the ascendence right now. Many of the powerful are using it to gain power, which is their main goal. But many – not all, but many, and I am unable to say how many – of those voting for it are unaware of its dangers and are motivated by the dreamy “Imagine”-type vision in their heads. And of course many are voting for it because they think they will be the beneficiaries, whether they are also idealists or whether their calculation is merely “what’s in it for me?

Comments
Lady Justice takes her blindfold off — No Comments
HTML tags allowed in your comment: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>