Trump-haters: fake conservatives or changed minds?
I think the number one thing that two Trump administrations have taught us is that SO MANY “conservatives” saw the conservative movement as a money-making grift, and nothing more.
They never had actual values other than greed.
Consider people like Bill Kristol, the bald losers at The Lincoln Project, the “Bulwark” crowd, etc., etc.
I know they branded themselves initially as merely conservatives who were “opposing Trump,” yet the reality is that today they have fully gone over to the Democrat camp–a party now controlled by literal communists and jihadists.
They are now Democrats. They did this even though the modern Democrat Party stands wildly in opposition to every value they ever once claimed to hold dear.
That Democrat grift pays better, I guess.
These people never had conservative values. They saw our movement solely as something to be exploited, and when Trump kicked them to the curb they simply switched sides.
They did not grow. They did not have an intellectual awakening.
And yet they gave an awfully good imitation of being conservatives prior to Trump. At least, some of them did, such as Bill Kristol – although I suppose it depends on your definition of “conservative.” I have little doubt some are simply grifters, but I think that’s too simple an explanation for a number of them – although I’m not sure what that number might be.
Kristol, for example, was not a “neoconservative” in the classic sense I’ve written about on this blog – in other words, he was not a political changer up till Trump ran for office. His father Irving Kristol most definitely was a left-to-right changer, but Bill Kristol was not. He was a neoconservative, though, in the sense in which some people use the word: a person in favor of a very interventionist foreign policy. I’d say that was his most salient characteristic during his supposedly “conservative” years, and it had already put him at odds with the most isolationist wing of the right.
Otherwise, Kristol did seem to have conservative bona fides, and that portion of his history went on for decades:
After watching his father, Irving, help found the neoconservative movement, he joined the Reagan administration as an aide to Education Secretary William Bennett, a leading figure on the cultural right. Later, as chief of staff to Vice President Dan Quayle, he pressed President George H.W. Bush from the right on taxes.
In 1993, at the newly minted Project for the Republican Future, he helped direct the party’s successful effort to block President Bill Clinton’s health-care plan. He launched the conservative magazine The Weekly Standard and became a commentator for Fox News. He staunchly backed President George W. Bush’s Iraq War and promoted Sarah Palin for the vice presidency in 2008.
But Trump stuck in Kristol’s craw. The initial reasons seem pretty clear: Kristol didn’t like what he perceived as Trump’s isolationism, and he found him stylistically offensive. Trump didn’t play the usual polite game, and I think Kristol found that repugnant.
Were a certain number of such supposedly-conservative Trump-haters raised in conservatism like Kristol, adopting conservatism as a matter of course without really thinking too very deeply about it? And was their conservatism based partly on style, with Trump outraging them for stylistic reasons? Was there also pressure put on them to change; pressure emanating from less-conservative wives, families, and communities (especially academia or DC)? Are they basically snobs and Trump was just too declassé and Not Their Kind? Or was it a grift the whole time and they just changed the direction of the grift? I think the answers are not unitary for the entire group.
Kristol did attempt to explain, at least during Trump’s first term (the interview is from 2018):
I’m a conservative who’s been mugged by Trump. But I still think I’m a conservative. I’m trying to uphold what was true about conservatism. I consider myself a Reagan conservative.
Harwood: You don’t think your politics have changed?
Kristol: No, not much. I mean, pro-American leadership in the world. Anti-America First. Pro free trade pretty much. Moderate on immigration. Limited government, constitutional government.
In terms of the conservative movement, I do think it would be foolish to deny that Trump has exposed certain aspects of that movement as less healthy than I thought or hoped.
If you look at that list, you can see that Kristol really was at odds with Trump on many policies. So turning away from Trump made a certain amount of sense.
Turning towards the Democrats made no sense, however, except as a way to stop Trump and MAGA. So Kristol ended up allying with those who absolutely do not espouse the principles he claims to hold dear (or at least used to claim to hold dear).
What’s that all about? At least for Kristol, I think he really believes what he is espousing now. I think it started with extreme personal revulsion towards Trump’s style and disagreement with some of his policies, and then it segued into revulsion towards the party who supported Trump. This resulted in support for the party opposing him – the Democrats. And as that party veered further and further left, there was probably a great deal of rationalization by Kristol.
There’s also the fact that now he and the others do get rewards for being Republicans Who Turned. That’s often a better spot to be in than a plain old conservative mostly engaged in preaching to the choir. Those rewards help reinforce the change that’s already happened.
NOTE: This is just my guess. I don’t have any special access to Kristol or the others. But it makes most sense to me, from what I know of him. Prior to the Trump years I had some mild dealings with him because I used to write pieces for the online Weekly Standard, and I also was quite friendly with someone who’d known him for many years. When he “turned” later on, my friend professed to be very puzzled because Kristol had always seemed to have solid conservative principles, for the most part.

Your writing clearly expresses your frustration. This has been a great source of frustration for me as well.
And yet they gave an awfully good imitation of being conservatives prior to Trump.
Yes they did.
Turning towards the Democrats made no sense,
No it doesn’t.
I don’t have anything to add here, but I certainly feel your pain.
“Turning towards the Democrats made no sense, however.” Full stop.
As one who has been waiting out the Trump presidency (some good things, some bad things, but a bias towards prosperity) I am in shock from the mid-term results. But if I look honestly at the GOP in the Congress, I see completely passive, flabby non-thinkers who were turned out of office by knaves who should never be allowed near power. The next few years will be rough because of the nature of people who have been allowed in. That people who flew the GOP flag for so long have surrendered to and joined up with these characters is appalling in the extreme.