Israel/Palestine roundup: on the International Red Cross; Blinken; Hillary Clinton versus Netanyahu; and those violent Israeli settlers
You think UNRWA is bad? Well, it is. But so is the International Red Cross:
And Blinken just keeps getting worse:
“Israelis were dehumanized in the most horrific way on October 7, ”said Blinken in prepared remarks at a Tel Aviv press conference. “The hostages have been dehumanized every day since. But that cannot be a license to dehumanize others.”
The White House has not hidden its dissatisfaction with Israel over civilian casualties in the Gaza Strip and the humanitarian situation there throughout the war, but Wednesday’s critique was the harshest to date.
Cycle of violence yada yada. Fighting back against murderous terrorists who hide behind civilians is just like going out of your way to violate a ceasefire and torture and murder civilians. Got it, Blinken.
And then there’s Hillary:
“Netanyahu should go. He is not a trustworthy leader. It was on his watch that the [October 7] attack happened. He needs to go, and if he’s an obstacle to a ceasefire, if he’s an obstacle to exploring what’s to be done the day after, he absolutely needs to go,” Clinton told MSNBC’s “Alex Wagner Tonight” in an interview.
She’s sad that the Obama-esque left can’t push Netanyahu around as well as it would like, and that he’s determined to defend Israel’s survival.
And then there’s this article on the Biden administration’s infuriating demonizing of Israeli “settlers.” You really need to read the whole thing, but here are some excerpts:
Instead of focusing on Hamas or Hezbollah, the lawmakers in attendance [early November], sources told Tablet, including senior ranking senators from both parties, wanted to focus on the risks posed by Israel—specifically, by roving bands of allegedly violent settlers in the West Bank. Lawmakers pressed the Israeli officials, going so far as to assert that uniformed IDF soldiers were escorting Israeli settlers to attack Palestinians.
Much of the information that these lawmakers were citing came from a single, ostensibly impartial source whose words carry weight in Washington in part because of his rank: Lieutenant General Michael R. Fenzel, a three-star general who currently serves as the U.S. Security Coordinator to Israel and the Palestinian Authority, colloquially known as the USSC. Fenzel’s USSC is well-known for its regular, sometimes daily briefings and reports about “extremist settlers,” which it provides to members of Congress, policy hands, Israel-related advocacy groups, as well as to foreign countries’ forces in Israel. …
According to sources in and out of the U.S. government familiar with Fenzel’s reports and advocacy, nearly every claim presented by the USSC as fact seems to have been lifted directly, sometimes verbatim, from the websites of highly partisan pro-Palestinian organizations, including the United Nations’ Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs in the Occupied Palestinian Territory (OCHA) and the far-left Israeli NGO B’Tselem, which accuses Israel of apartheid and receives vast support from European governments and from George Soros’ Open Society Foundations.
In the past 12 months, 13 Israelis were murdered by Palestinians in Jerusalem and 17 in the West Bank—not counting those slaughtered on October 7, 2023—while doing nothing more provocative than driving home or stopping for gas. The number of Palestinian civilians who have been killed by Israelis under such conditions over the same time period is zero.
But the story the administration has been telling anyone who will listen is very different. By scrubbing any mention of the daily violence directed by Palestinian terror operatives against Jewish civilians living in the West Bank from his reports, Fenzel has eliminated the clear retaliatory motive for the vast majority of attacks by Israelis against West Bank Palestinians. Thinly laundered reports from expressly anti-Israel organizations, designed to support an illusion of innocent Palestinians being violently attacked by bloodthirsty Israelis, paint a picture of an Israeli equivalent to the Palestinian atrocities of Oct. 7, lending itself an easy “both-sides” posture meant to ease the way to creating a new Palestinian state in both the West Bank and Gaza. With an executive order now in place, the Biden administration has all the tools it needs to crack down on any form of Jewish life in Judea and Samaria, and on anyone, in Israel or stateside, who supports it.
This is the way Palestinian propaganda works. And many administrations, and the press, have swallowed it whole for decades. Why? Fools or knaves or both? One might say it hardly matters. But at least stupidity or ignorance can sometimes be corrected by more information. Bad intentions cannot.
More:
B’Tselem echoed OCHA’s numbers, delivering an account of how each of the eight Palestinians killed by Israeli civilians in the West Bank before Oct.7 had died. The details, buried inside an online database, paint a stark picture: Abd al-Karim Badi’a, a 21-year-old, was shot by an Israeli settler after entering the settlement armed with knives and explosive devices. 42-year-old Tareq Odeh Yusef M’aali was shot by an Israeli settler after trying to stab the same settler in a field. Muhannad Falah Abdallah Shihadah, a Hamas terorrist, was killed after murdering four Israelis, including two minors, by shooting them to death outside the Jewish community of Eli.
According to OCHA and B’Tselem, the above all count as Palestinian victims. The USSC amplifies this claim.
Biden has taken the extraordinary step of censuring four Israeli “settlers” who have been accused of such violence – accused, according to the article, by “Palestinian authorities.” The sanctions involve “imposing financial sanctions and visa bans in an initial round against four individuals.”
The evidence against these individuals is very difficult to find, but it appears to be based on Palestinian accusations. I did a quick search and came up with this sort of thing, in which the West Bank family of a victim who was a “Palestinian-American” visiting the area accuse “a settler” of killing him. The incident, also described here, is being investigated by Israel, but I can’t even find an accused perp’s name much less whether the accused was one of Biden’s four sanctioned people.
However, here’s what one of the four says about the accusations he’s facing:
Yinon Levi spoke alongside his wife, Sapir Levi, on Tuesday in their outpost in the occupied West Bank. They told ABC News they don’t understand why he was sanctioned in Biden’s executive order.
Levi was accused of inciting violence against Palestinians and burning farmland. He said he has never been involved in an attack and they have not seen any evidence.
We don’t need no steenking evidence.
More [emphasis mine]:
Secretary of State Antony Blinken, in a Feb. 1 statement, said Yinon Levi allegedly led a group of settlers “who engaged in actions creating an atmosphere of fear in the West Bank” and “repeatedly attacked multiple communities within the West Bank.”
“He regularly led groups of settlers from the Meitarim Farm outpost that assaulted Palestinian and Bedouin civilians, threatened them with additional violence if they did not leave their homes, burned their fields, and destroyed their property,” the statement said.
Local residents and activists told ABC News they believe Yinon Levi is shown on video operating a bulldozer to allegedly block roads in Susya in the West Bank on Oct. 16, 2023. Satellite imagery from Oct. 17, 2023, appears to show dirt disturbed over a road in Susya.
Basel Adra, who lives in a village near Susya, said Yinon Levi also destroyed water wells and agricultural fields for crops like olives and grapes.
Although ABC News could not independently verify claims of property destruction, Levi was described in the sanctions order as destroying property.
ABC News also obtained videos, from April 2022 and March 2023, of Yinon Levi with his dog discouraging Arabs from herding sheep in the area and harassing activists.
In response to the videos, Yinon Levi said “Anarchists come to our territory and do provocations. They disturb the soldiers, they attack us, the dog and the sheep on purpose and document it for provocation.”
That’s it, apparently.
The Biden administration is doing this to placate their rather large left flank by repeating the propaganda of the West Bank.
Israel doesn’t want reoccupy Gaza, but also doesn’t want it to return to Jew hating Palestinian control. The Israelis need to get used to the idea that it only be peaceful if it is pacified, and kept pacified, by Israel.
Like in creating a Gaza Confederation, with lots of clan influence in each of the 5 cantons.
In a talk between Arnold Kling & Moshe Koppel, the idea of forcibly secularizing the area was claimed to be unfeasible, unrealistic. My claim is that allowing Jew hate, either thru religion or other orgs, guarantees more crimes against Jews.
Koppel is an ai expert who developed an ai system to help read ancient texts, especially in Hebrew. He’s also the conservative libertarian head of the think tank most responsible for proposing judicial reforms that progressive Israelis hate and protested against. Link in near future when Kling uploads it. The talk was mostly the reading of ancient texts.
Gideon Klein, String Trio, [1944], completed under the watchful eye of the Red Cross at Theresienstadt/Terezin two weeks prior to his deportation to Auschwitz/Birkenau where he perished in a sub-camp 9 days before Auschwitz/Birkenau was liberated on Jan. 27 1945.
“Untrustworthy,” says the unpleasant harpy. I think she thinks the word means “somebody I dislike,” not “someone who cannot be trusted.”
And I should add that the left’s whole problem with “settlers” really goes back much further than the Israeli – Palestinian conflict. If you’ve been listening lately to what Democrats say, they really don’t like the settlers who founded this country.
UNSCR 2334 Ho!!
(“Biden”‘s version: UNSCR 2334 Ha!!)
Cf. https://www.goodreads.com/en/book/show/709811
https://www.timesofisrael.com/choosing-not-to-veto-obama-lets-anti-settlement-resolution-pass-at-un-security-council/
But TRUMP!!
The administration essentially is saying that while reasonable people would agree that not EVERY Israeli bakes matzoh with Muslim blood, the Jews are a dastardly lot, in general, and get what they deserve.
Sgt Joe Friday
I don’t think it’s someone Hillary doesn’t like, I think it’s someone who didn’t give her sufficient Dane Geld when she was Secretary of State.
As for how Israel is being slandered in the non-jewish world, and how the slander is growing as time passes, the government of Israel would be justified in believing they have no friends in international organizations or in any foreign government (including the USA), how long will it be before the State Department gets the picture that they are driving all Israeli governments to the point that no violence will be too great for them. If October 7, or anything similar happens in the future, Israel can be expected to use the most powerful weapons they have on Palestinians, on Iran, and on anybody else they suspect had anything to do with the attack — including the UN.
We are governed by a bunch of cabbage-heads. What can you expect of this crew? Good judgement? Naaaah.
Hillary Clinton should be quiet about the “he must go” talk. She’s the one who had Qaddafi in Libya eliminated, with horrifying results for Libyans and for the African blacks who are sold as slaves there, and for Copts who were executed on the beach.
“…how long will it be before the State Department gets the picture that they are driving all Israeli governments to the point that no violence will be too great for them….”
Time to send that Carrier group back to the Eastern Mediterranean.
– – – – – – – – –
Ah Cicero, IF ONLY they WERE “cabbage-heads”…
Hillary.
She’s rested and ready.
Put ‘er in coach… she’s ready to play.
But do keep the “van” running in case the gin wears her down and she needs the sack-of-potatoes treatment again.
John Guilfoyle: Thread winner!
But you do know the FBI is reading this, don’t you?
The American Left has been trying to get rid of Netanyahu for years. Clinton sent “advisors” to interfere in Israeli elections. Obama the same.
So…….According to our ‘Progressives’, it’s time to give Texas back to ……..
the Commanche? Spain, and later Mexico, claimed Texas but never dislodged the Commanche.
Now the Commanche took it from the Apaches, but that’s a different quarrel, isn’t it?
well remember that native american crew, that want to dismantle the country up in minnesota, or the zombie kindergarten director,