Balancing the Israel/Palestine scale requires lies
As far back as I can remember – and since I’m pretty old these days, that’s quite far back – the MSM was interested in a particular narrative about Israel and Palestine. Let’s call it “equivalence.” Certain concepts were involved, but especially the “cycle of violence” – as though the entire thing was some sort of children’s squabble in which both sides were trading punches and neither side wanted the conflict to end.
And those were the media outlets who were relatively kind to the Israelis. There were others who put the blame squarely on the Israelis and saw Palestinians as their long-suffering victims.
To maintain such fictions it was necessary for the MSM to lie and to obscure. But the MSM was fully up to the task. Some of what reporters did was out of a combination of laziness and ignorance. Some was leftist anti-Semitism in which hatred of Jews combined with hatred of the Western world and the Enlightenment. Some was the need to cater to the Palestinians in order to preserve “access,” without which this illusion of coverage couldn’t happen. And some of the reporters have been Palestinian stringers whose sympathies were and are obviously with their fellow Palestinians and their terrorist leaders and against Israel
For example – and I know this looks like it’s from the Babylon Bee, but it’s not – here’s the latest from The NY Times:
The New York Times is defending its rehiring of a Gaza journalist who was previously exposed for praising Hitler.
The Times rehired freelance videographer Soliman Hijjy as part of its coverage of the Israel-Hamas war. In August 2022, the pro-Israel media watchdog HonestReporting shed light on Hijjy, whose work had been featured by the Times between 2018 and 2021.
HonestReporting found that Hijjy praised Adolf Hitler in a 2012 Facebook post, writing, “How great you are, Hitler” in Arabic.
In a 2018 post, Hijjy shared a photo of himself with a caption that translated to either “I’m in tune like Hitler during the holocaust” or “in a state of harmony as Hitler was during the Holocaust.” …
The Times is now standing by Hijjy.
“We reviewed problematic social media posts by Mr. Hijjy when they first came to light in 2022 and took a variety of actions to ensure he understood our concerns and could adhere to our standards if he wished to do freelance work for us in the future,” a spokesperson for the Times told FOX News Digital. “Mr. Hijjy followed those steps and has maintained high journalistic standards. He has delivered important and impartial work at great personal risk in Gaza during this conflict.”
This is beyond parody.
Most MSM reporters aren’t as obviously biased as Hijjy, but they nevertheless only feel comfortable when they can pretend that Israel is just as bad as Hamas. That’s why they were so very eager to take Hamas’ world for the hospital bombing. It was too good to not be true. And the fact that they were exposed as the liars they are will not stop them from doing it again and again, as they’ve done for decades.
Ben Shapiro writes:
The easiest moral place to stand is in the middle.
Standing in the middle is comforting. It grants you the illusion that you are being evenhanded, that you see nuance and complexity where others see black and white. It is flattering to be in the middle — no one hates your viewpoint enough to make you their opponent, and yet you get to stand apart from everyone, tut-tutting both sides.
When it comes to Israel and its terror-backing enemies, the West has, for some decades, taken precisely that position.
And those are the better reporters. The worse ones firmly take the Palestinian side.
As Shapiro writes, it’s based on lies:
The first lie is that Israel must be warned not to engage in human rights violations.
We hear this nostrum all the time: from the president of the United States, from the United Nations, from the media. The idea is that if Israel’s leadership isn’t reminded in the wake of the worst pogrom since the Holocaust, those rude Jews might carpet-bomb Gaza. The purpose of the lie is simple: to get Israel to stop defending itself at the first available opportunity. If you warn the world that Israel is likely to pursue atrocities, and then — as inevitably happens in war — something terrible happens, Israel can quickly be shoved back into the box of moral equivalence.
Voila! Status quo ante restored.
Of course, this lie is a lie. And it is a stupidly offensive lie, in the same way that it is a lie when the United Nations warns the United States about human rights violations. Israel is a professional military that abides by the rules of war. Its enemies openly cheer the death of civilians, both Israel’s and their own. By all rights, the entire political and media infrastructure ought to be using their supposed moral suasion on human rights to convince Hamas to release hostages and protect their own citizens. But, of course, there’s no real interest in that. The lie must be maintained. Israel has to be warned about human rights, because secretly, the Jews are just like Hamas.
Then there’s the second lie: that we must all remember the vaunted Peace Process …
The Peace Process is dead. It always was a fiction, but Hamas killed the last lingering remnants of that fiction and wiped its bloody sword on it.
NOTE: I’m not sure where best to put the following, which is a comment I saw to this article. I can’t vouch for its veracity, but to me it has the ring of truth, as well as (sadly) familiarity in its m.o.:
In 88-89 I was a reserve member of the military Govt in Gaza. I hated being there and requested to transfer back to my original unit in Lebanon but to no avail so I did my job of trying to keep the peace and stop Hamas from spreading out of the neighborhood of Ally Muktar, I was in the house of Yasseen [Hamas head at the time] twice as our officers tried to explain to him what he was doing to the city. But the blind fkr couldn’t see it nor would he listen.
Afterwards we had an emergency call to investigate a crime scene. The man of the house was tied to a chair badly beaten and bleeding profusely from stab wounds. His wife [and] daughters … lay on the floor lifeless in their own blood, having been tortured, raped, and killed while the father was forced to watch. This happened because he didn’t want to join Hamas.
As our medics tended to his wounds he dipped his hand in the blood of his family and swore that he would avenge them. I never knew if he came back from the hospital in Ashkalon.
But I saw this happen a few more times after this.
This is how Hamas got the vote by the people.
An “l” slipped into a “word.” I’m pretty sure that’s a typo, but I kinda’ like it that way.
“That’s why they were so very eager to take Hamas’ world for the hospital bombing.”
Joe Biden is on the side of Israel’s enemy, plain as day:
JNS TV, Melanie Phillips interviewed by host Jonathan Tobin, “The Murderous Consequences of Western Diplomacy” (skip in to 8:30 to Melanie’s first appearance): https://youtu.be/d6cdgjeIejU?si=1jYeasFN7cMyqs4C
Neo: “The Peace Process is dead. It always was a fiction . . .”
Yes, it always was a fiction; it was really a “we, the PLO, Hamas, (whatever the latest name for that evil is) are losing so we need to pretend to a cease fire/peace process so that we can re-group.”
And that Israel so many times tried it shows how much Israelis just want to live in peace and be left alone.
“To maintain such fictions it was necessary for the MSM to lie and to obscure. – And the fact that they were exposed as the liars they are will not stop them from doing it again and again, as they’ve done for decades.”
To lie is to knowingly tell an untruth with the intent to deceive. It is an attack upon the truth. Given the special privileges that the media operates under, it is a form of perjury.
At base, it is an attempt to prevail through cheating and an implicit admission that the position they support cannot stand upon its own merits.
They condemn themselves out of their own mouths.
its called a hudna, see hudabiya, for examples,
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12672025/Fury-Queen-Rania-Jordans-grotesque-interview-attacking-Israel-Gaza-strikes-questioning-Hamas-killed-babies.html
Caroline Glick’s latest talk, a very powerful discussion of good and evil and the fault of the western world in the treatment of Israel in the war against Hamas. Be prepared to be made very angry and upset.
https://youtu.be/drfOR5M-jd0?si=rrogQQnz4sZwDDpi
Michael Millerman, “Israel: Jewish, Democratic, and Territorial? A Legal Analysis of a Flawed Model.” (1:19:57) —
https://youtu.be/Cc7hfDXSuec?si=pFUdixd3LsT66mq1
The Melanie Phillips interview led me to this remarkable interview of a young woman who miraculously survived the attack on the music festival. She’s obviously a hippie but has a few choice words for the Gaza sympathizers in the west. Among other things she points out that there were thousands of Gazan “civilians” raping, killing, and looting in addition to the Hamas operatives. 22 minutes but easily followed at 1.5x.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jnlW7tWykyA
Related:
Some not terribly encouraging news about Britain from Bruce Bawer:
“There’ll Always Be an England?;
“Since October 7, prospects are looking worse than ever.”—
https://www.frontpagemag.com/therell-always-be-an-england/
H/T Instapundit.
OTOH, is there any encouraging news from anywhere?
As Neo said yesterday, there is far too much in the news to take it all in.
The pundits outnumber us 100 to 1.
Thanks to Neo and the Salon here for narrowing down the flow and pointing out so many important posts that bear reading, although there is not enough time and space for the full discussion many of them deserve.
However, in keeping with the topic if this post, here is an entry for the Gaslighting and Goal-post Moving Olympics.
https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/10/the-most-incoherent-conservative-take-on-israel-yet.html
The author addresses the Kisin post “The Day the Delusions Died,” which we’ve previously considered, and the Sowell world-view in his 1987 book, A Conflict of Visions.
He doesn’t like them.
Examples of one obfuscation technique (there are others):
“Just four paragraphs into Kisin’s piece, the reader is already knee-deep in fallacies. For one thing, no progressive with any political power has called for the complete elimination of all economic inequality.”
Throwing Bernie and Friends under the bus?
“The spectacle of putative progressives cheering an Islamist group’s mass murder of Jewish children certainly heightened these contradictions.
Of course, a rational liberal observer would recognize that such moral idiocy was confined to a small minority of the left, one with negligible political power.”
Throwing The Squad under the bus?
That said, he raises questions (literally) that should be addressed, in order to clarify his spin and thereafter either refute it or correct errors that actually might exist in Kisin’s work (possibly) or Sowell’s (unlikely) — or even revise one’s own opinions, if so inclined.
@ Barry – I linked this in another thread, but I believe it is very encouraging.
https://www.timesofisrael.com/in-stunning-response-15000-volunteers-fill-leadership-vacuum-to-help-victims-of-hamas/
I hope these feelings last.
Lies by omission.
https://www.dailywire.com/news/abc-nbc-cbs-give-zero-airtime-to-pro-hamas-squad-dems-following-terrorist-attacks
If you still read Foreign Affairs, you can stop now.
https://freebeacon.com/biden-administration/in-foreign-affairs-essay-national-security-adviser-jake-sullivan-said-biden-has-de-escalated-crises-in-gaza-then-he-erased-the-evidence/
“Biden”‘s ally consolidates its position.
(“Biden” pedals furiously to obfuscate.)…
“Tehran Makes Its Moves on the Border of Israel Amid Gaza Standoff”—
https://www.meforum.org/65088/tehran-makes-its-moves-on-the-border-of-israel
On a par with:
‘Global Anti-Israel and Anti-Jewish Hate consolidates its position.
(“Biden” pedals furiously to obfuscate.)’…
https://www.powerlineblog.com/archives/2023/10/what-manner-of-moron-is-this.php
https://www.powerlineblog.com/archives/2023/10/a-moronic-sequel.php
+ Bonus:
“JOURNALISTS FOR MASS MURDER AND GANG RAPE”—
https://www.powerlineblog.com/archives/2023/10/journalists-for-mass-murder-and-gang-rape.php
Things change gradually, then suddenly.
https://www.tabletmag.com/sections/history/articles/when-americas-democratic-socialists-proudly-supported-israel
“For decades, the DSA and its predecessors, and socialist leaders like Michael Harrington and Bayard Rustin, championed the Jewish state and defended Jews on campus. In 2017, the DSA embraced Jew-hatred.”
That was only 6 years ago.
Good companion piece to the history in the above post.
https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1717165815181480280.html
As the post-mortem analyses continue to pour in…
This one, which could have been written by Wretchard, happens to be particularly apt (but read also the comment by Mr. McKee):
“Israel’s illusion of security;
“Military technology has become a false idol”—
https://archive.md/w3klc
(Remains to be seen whether the antidote has been (or can be) implemented in time…)
“…then suddenly…”
So how did we get here?
“The tyranny of pathological kindness;
“The cruel streak in progressivism has become dominant”—
https://unherd.com/2023/10/the-tyranny-of-pathological-kindness/
Key grafs (RTWT):
‘…Acts of kindness bear witness to our shared suffering. But when kindness becomes pathological, it is cruel and divisive — as with [the above] examples. And it is on the rise. In the West today, there are people whose suffering is deemed to be non-existent or of little value, and so judgement takes the place of understanding, punishment that of mercy. The result is a purity spiral whereby extreme kindness towards an in-group gives unlimited licence to act with cruelty towards an out-group. It’s this licence that gives progressive activists permission to clothe antisemitism as anti-colonialism.
‘ Following the Hamas massacre, a lecturer at Stanford University used “identity-based targeting” to force three Jewish students to stand in a corner so they could feel “what Israel does to Palestinians”. He asked them how many Jews died in the Holocaust. One of the students said “six million” and the lecturer replied that “colonizers killed more than 6 million. Israel is a colonizer”. In New York, activists tore down posters pleading for the safe release of Jewish hostages, many of them women and children, while London saw a 1,353% increase in antisemitic attacks.
‘ In the intersectional narrative inhaled by activists, kindness for the “oppressed” legitimises unspeakable cruelty against the “oppressor”….’
[All emphasis mine; Barry M.]
And so, here we are…
(Though I don’t think the author gives enough “credit” or credence to the massive lying and propaganda mainstreamed and amplified via the media and, especially, social media.)
And might the experiences and conclusions regarding THIS author’s intense Dantesque journey into the vortex of faith provide an explanation of a sort…to the conundrum—almost RELIGIOUS(?)—described in the exposition on the “progressivist” cult in my previous comment…
“Reverend Pilavachi’s irresistible charisma;
“My faith left me with an awful, gnawing hollowness”—
https://unherd.com/2023/10/reverend-pilavachis-irresistible-charisma/
Related (from Victor D. Hanson):
“The Hamas One-Eyed Jack”—
https://twitter.com/vdhanson/status/1717256162134184256
H/T Powerline blog.
Concluding grafs (RTWT):
‘…So yes, much of the acclaim for Hamas is not just found in its ferocious barbarity, but also fueled by a feeling that the killers are “winning” the propaganda war. Thus their cowardly but useful idiots of the West increasingly ally with the “oppressed” oppressor that can both butcher and claim victimhood simultaneously—and not only get away with it, but win global support for it.
‘And this is all the more reason why Israel must crush and thereby humiliate Hamas—as a lesson to its numerous enemies that the price for butchering innocents will always be too steep for even mass murderers to pay.’
Professor Hanson clearly articulates why massive—and DECISIVE—“pedagogical” response is required in the current case.
And no, this point, is nowhere near understood by the usual suspects…
David Harsanyi, firing on all cylinders…with some “inconvenient truths”…about Democratic Party perfidy.
“On Israel, Biden Picks Up Where Obama Left Off”—
https://thefederalist.com/2023/10/25/on-israel-biden-picks-up-where-obama-left-off/
H/T Powerline blog.
My only quibble with the article is that “Biden” IS Obama…but this may be the headline writer’s fault and not Harsanyi’s.
FWIW (but don’t tell Queen Rania…not that she’d believe it in any event…)
“Gaza resident reveals how Hamas prevents civilians from escaping northern Gaza;
“A Gaza resident who was told to leave before IDF strikes says Hamas is blocking roads and shooting those attempting to leave.”—
https://www.israelnationalnews.com/news/379205
Not that any of this should be surprising…
(or alas convincing…)
Related:
“Israel Agrees to Delay Gaza Ground Invasion until U.S. Can Deploy Air-Defense Systems”—
https://www.nationalreview.com/news/israel-agrees-to-delay-gaza-ground-invasion-until-u-s-can-deploy-air-defense-systems/
H/T Powerline blog.
…Since, apparently, American troops can’t, per “Biden”, defend themselves.
(And NOT forgetting, either, “Biden”‘s sincere and concerted efforts to PROTECT American troops—and others—during the Afghanistan debacle…)
Opening grafs (to this gobsmackingly pernicious absurdity, the true intentions of which should be obvious):
“Israel has agreed to delay its impending ground invasion of Gaza until the U.S. can establish air defenses to protect U.S. troops throughout the region.
“The Pentagon has requested that Israel hold off until they can deploy nearly a dozen air-defense systems to the region, the Wall Street Journal first reported. The missile deployments, which are expected to be completed in the coming days, are intended to shield U.S. troops serving in Iraq, Syria, Kuwait, Jordan, Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates from enemy rockets and missiles….”
“Hold off” meaning what, exactly? (Forever and a day, perhaps?)
And Israel has, apparently, agreed…but two can play the same game…as in;
“No, we’re not invading…it’s just a ‘pre-invasion’…”
To be sure, “Biden” has some leverage that he can use.
The 64 quadrazillion dollar question: Will he allow Israel to force “his” hand?
(Foolish question: “he” already has…if not to the full extent “he” is prepared to go…to save Israel from itself, but OF COURSE!)
AF @ 12:22 am
One would hope so…
…but the hatred, from what I can ascertain is still simmering, even seething, underground in some…unfortunately.
One hopes that that “some” is a relatively small number…but I’m not sure.
– – – – – – – –
And another “Changer” story.
(One marvels, though—um, that should be “shudders”—at the extraordinary delusions that seem so easily to be embraced in the first place…)
“Hamas Killed My Wokeness;
“I’ve found a home on the progressive left for years—even after I noticed a common blind spot around Jewish issues. But the reaction to the murderous attacks on Israeli civilians was the final straw.”—
https://www.tabletmag.com/sections/community/articles/hamas-slaughtered-wokeness
Key grafs:
(To tell you the truth, after reading the first two or three grafs, I’m not even sure it’s worth the time and effort…)
“Biden”-esque “Realism”—together with journalistic integrity—a heady mix!
“Magazine scrubs sections of Jake Sullivan’s essay praising Biden’s performance in the Middle East”—
https://nypost.com/2023/10/25/news/magazine-scrubs-sections-of-national-security-adviser-jake-sullivans-essay-praising-bidens-performance-in-the-middle-east/
Gosh, would this be THE Jake Sullivan who mentioned not too long ago that the Middle East is currently the most peaceful it’s been in decades…thanks to the amazing “Biden”‘s iron grasp of ME policy…
Here’s the more comprehensive Powerline blog treatment of ‘Biden-esque “Realism” ‘, above.
“THE SULLIVAN REWRITE”—
https://www.powerlineblog.com/archives/2023/10/the-sullivan-rewrite.php
State of the Nation…or…Where We Stand:
“Warfare by Immigration”—
https://americanmind.org/salvo/warfare-by-immigration/
H/T Powerline blog.
Key grafs:
‘…China’s support today of Hamas, Hezbollah, and the Islamic Republic of Iran demonstrates their role as leader of a global Communist movement, allied with the Islamic World, which seeks to destroy America and the West. They have little reason to doubt that they are winning. In London, 100,000 protestors, most of them Muslim immigrants, defended the attack by Hamas on Israel. American cities have seen similar displays.
‘ It bears repeating for this generation that the goal, now as then, is the destruction of the West. Israel was, and is, an outpost of the West and a defender of human freedom. Terrorist campaigns to destroy Israel were useful to animate certain parts of the Islamic world on behalf of the protracted war the Communists were waging against human freedom. These were once well-understood features of the ideological and political war between the Soviet Union and the United States. They have somehow been forgotten.
‘ Indeed, the very idea of the West has largely been abandoned. At its best, the West presented to the world an intellectual defense of freedom of the mind, freedom of religion, and the freedom of peoples to determine how they would govern themselves. It represented man’s highest aspirations….
‘ Although these beliefs are still held by the American people, they appear to have largely been rejected by U.S. elites. Witness the rejection of American principles in the modern university and the administrative state that runs our country.
‘ The difference between the Cold War and today is that the Soviets and the Chinese could not, back then, contemplate a United States that would open its borders to millions of people from all over the planet, regardless of their country of origin or political views. There was always immigration of course, including illegal immigration…. The opening of the U.S. border today reveals an America engaged in a kind of national suicide.
‘ Given such weakness, we should not then be surprised that America’s major cities and her capitol have been filled with protesters who march in solidarity with Hamas and their deadly attack on Israel. It makes no difference that these protests purport to be in support of the Palestinian cause. Their practical effect is the support of terrorism and murder….
‘ One of the first acts of the Biden Administration was to restore $200 million in funding to the Palestinian Authority, which had been cut off by the Trump Administration because it was being used to support the terrorist activities of Hamas. That fact will not be lost on any of these leftist groups. Nor will the fact that the Biden Administration facilitated billions of dollars in direct money transfers, oil sales, and forward contracts to Hamas’s central ally, the Islamic Republic of Iran, and Iran’s central ally, the Chinese Communist Party.
‘ The Biden Administration made the decision to support a global alliance led by Communist China that was antithetical to the interests of the United States. In so doing, President Biden has not only turned against one of America’s closest friends, the state of Israel, but has signaled to the Communist movements within the United States on whose side he stands. Needless to say, Israel must be prepared to go it alone under these circumstances….
‘ At an important level, the Biden Administration—–despite Joe Biden’s pronouncements about the need for greater U.S. support of Israel and his embrace of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu—–shares ideologically the broad animus that the pan-Islamic world has for the West in general and the United States and Israel in particular…. He has surrounded himself with a State Department and National Security Council who share the American Left’s disdain for what America represents. What else is to explain the support of Communist China, Iran, Hamas, and Hezbollah? And what is to explain the knowing importation of 5.1 million new illegal immigrants during the past two and a half years, on top of the 13 to 20 million illegal immigrants that were already here?….’
[All emphasis mine; Barry M.]
File under: Karl Schwab’s WTF/WEF
@ Barry > “To tell you the truth, after reading the first two or three grafs, I’m not even sure it’s worth the time and effort…”
It was, even if just to raise the click-count of this and similar stories.
We need to demonstrate that the radical nihilist antisemitic evil Left is NOT a defining faction of America, or even a majority (I hope) of the liberal-left useful idiots.
Alinsky rules: marginalize the opposition, because they are the fringe on the margin, for now, although metastasizing rapidly.
Encourage changers any way we can.
}}} I can’t vouch for its veracity, but to me it has the ring of truth, as well as (sadly) familiarity in its m.o.:
The world needs more snipers taking out evil men (and, in some cases, perhaps, women).
}}} We need to demonstrate that the radical nihilist antisemitic evil Left is NOT a defining faction of America, or even a majority (I hope) of the liberal-left useful idiots.
There was a time when The Left had moderates. I don’t see it any more. The Left is all PostModern Liberals — at least 95% of them — as opposed to “classical” liberals.
They are the sort of liberal Truman referred to as “Professional” liberals:
https://www.americanheritage.com/eight-days-harry-truman
“Moderate” liberals are about as scarce on the ground as “Moderate” Muslims. Yes, they exist, but they are very thin on the ground…