Home » Melanie Phillips writes about what’s going on in Israel with Ehud Barak

Comments

Melanie Phillips writes about what’s going on in Israel with Ehud Barak — 17 Comments

  1. I have often wondered what would have happened had the Democrats failed to find enough mail-in-ballots to win the Presidency in 2020- a coup was at the top my list.

  2. Need to see the transcript. Seems outlandish.
    ==
    Recall that Barak is pure poison politically. The Labor Party and its precursors won a plurality in every election held from 1920 to 1973. They were the lead party in every coalition government for 29 years (1948-77). They were a vigorous competitor to Likud for 24 years (1977-2001). Then they began crashing down hill. Bar one reprieve, they lost their position as the principal opposition party in 2009 and by 2019 they’d joined the ranks of Israel’s many splinter parties, corralling 4.5% of the electorate. The almost relentless decline – as if the actuarial tables were chewing the party to pieces – began with Barak’s tenure and the catastrophic failure of his diplomatic initiatives in 2000. His last effort was to form another splinter party and associate it with a mess of extant Green organizations and lefty dissenters, principally Meretz. They scored some seats in one election (principally Meretz members) then disappeared.

  3. Oof, what a nasty little man. Don’t be fooled by the heroics from his early days (see, e.g., John McCain) nor shamed into silence by his grievous family history.

  4. Isreal and the United States are vastly different countries with vastly different social, cultural and political structures. Moreover, while they share some personality traits and a fair bit of their nationalistic outlook, Bibi and Trump are vastly different men.

    Nonetheless, it behooves us to pay close attention to what is happening to Bibi. It is not at all outside the realm of possibility that something similar will happen to Trump (or any Republican) should the GOP win the White House in 2024.

  5. Another color revolution, sigh.

    So many similarities with the events leading up to 2020 us election.

  6. if memory serves, he was bibi’s boss at sayaret metkal, the israeli special forces unit, he was also strongly tied to epstein in the last few years,

  7. Ray SoCa:

    One thing it’s important to understand – whether about Barak or tons of other people left of center – is that Epstein was a rich guy who donated a lot of money to liberal and leftist causes. Many people who met with him had relationships with him that had to do with that. As for the sex stuff, we certainly know Epstein was guilty, and a few other people have been implicated (falsely or correctly) by some of the women, but it is almost certainly the case that a great many people connected with Epstein were not part of that. What the percentages are is anyone’s guess. The rumor mill flies. But I see no particular reason to think that the majority were doing the sex stuff.

  8. Barak, Barack, Barack, Barak
    Let’s call the whole thing off!

    –apologies to George Gershwin

  9. Personal bravery and military aptitude don’t necessarily translate to conservative or even moderate politics. The myth of an egalitarian society can be believed by heroes and villains alike.

    Bibi certainly seems to draw the hatred of lefties. Much like Trump does here. It’s a terrible thing for both countries.

  10. I can attest that Netanyahu’s superb autobiography Bibi contains some poison pen for Barak. Here’s how Andrew Roberts characterized it in the Claremont Review of Books, https://claremontreviewofbooks.com/the-churchill-of-the-middle-east/:

    Although there are excellent pen portraits of Yitzhak Rabin, Ariel Sharon, Shimon Peres, Yitzhak Shamir, and several other Israeli politicians, Ehud Barak will not be happy with the way he is portrayed in relation to the Sabena operation at Lod Airport, as “a bystander. His only role in storming the plane was standing on the tarmac and blowing a whistle. Four of his decorations were given not for leadership under fire but for intelligence gathering operations.” Ouch!

  11. Neo – My gut feeling is Epstein’s foibles with an underage harem were used as a honey pot for at least one Intel agency. The recording, and how those have disappeared, are very suspicious.

    The innocent explanation is Epstein just had a kinky habits of recording powerful guests, and the FBI protected innocent blackmailed parties by slow walking warrants to get the recordings.

    And perhaps Barak was just looking for funding for his liberal, political party from Epstein. Or repaying a debt to help out Epstein.

  12. JJ on July 31, 2023 at 11:30 pm said:
    Personal bravery and military aptitude don’t necessarily translate to conservative or even moderate politics. The myth of an egalitarian society can be believed by heroes and villains alike.
    ________

    Exactly. It’s an error to think that if someone is admirable in some way(s), it follows that he is in others. I think this has something to do with the desire to stick up for artists and athletes.

    I have a friend who likes to point out that, had Benedict Arnold died of his wounds at Saratoga, there’d be high schools all over America named after him. And had Petain died in 1939, the same would be true in France.

  13. One thing that is interesting is that such deep societal divisions have opened up in 3 stalwarts of the West.
    Whose next and what is the reason for such “coincidental” timing?

  14. And perhaps Barak was just looking for funding for his liberal, political party from Epstein. Or repaying a debt to help out Epstein.
    ==
    Barak formed the Israel Democratic Party just two weeks before Epstein was clapped in jail for the last time. That wasn’t the reason.
    ==
    If Barak did meet with Epstein 20x, that is … inneresting.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

HTML tags allowed in your comment: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>