Home » Murder in Memphis

Comments

Murder in Memphis — 26 Comments

  1. The Memphis Flyer piece was inconvenient for the powers that be, and no longer exists. It still shows up in Google search, but even that will likely be gone in a day or so.

  2. A few things,
    If Abston is 38 now; then in 2001, he’d be about 17, which seems young for kidnapping and murder.
    If 17 and he plead guilty, was that as an adult?
    Even as an adult, my understanding with sentences is you are in prison for half and the other half is used as incentive for good behavior. Behave, and you might get your sentences cut in half. IF that is the case for this Abston, then 12+5.5=17.5, which leaves some slack between 2001 and now.

    If Abston was 38 at the original crime, then I think the criminal justice system was too lenient, especially in hindsight. If Abston was 17 and pleaded guilty, then I can’t imagine a criminal justice system being tougher than it was. Right now, our criminal justice system is completely whack. Violent criminals are barely arrested before being let back on the street. Every other month in Houston, there is a new story of a criminal out on bail committing murder. Here’s a similar case in Minnesota. Sadly, Eliza Fletcher won’t even become statistic, because her killer murdered his victims one at a time instead of all at once and with a firearm.

  3. As I read it, Abston was 16 or 17 on the first offense, and got a sentence consistent with his age and his crime. There is no way to prevent evil people from doing awful things.

    RIP Eliza.

  4. There is no way to prevent evil people from doing awful things.

    Try deterrence and incapacitation.

  5. “Seven in 10 incarcerated people released in 34 states in 2012 were rearrested within five years, according to a Bureau of Justice Statistics (BJS) report on recidivism rates for prisoners in 34 states between 2012 and 2017.”
    https://thecrimereport.org/2021/07/30/us-recidivism-rates-stay-sky-high/

    3 felony strikes: no release until age 67… no possibility of parole.

    Castration for child abusers and rape.

    Reinstate the death penalty for child rape, kidnapping, voluntary manslaughter and murder.

  6. What is the use of a “concurrent” sentence? is your cell half as big as if you had only one sentence? Half as many desserts at meal time?

  7. Fletcher’s murder reminded me that it’s been a long time since I’ve seen a woman jogging alone in my neighborhood. There are plenty of joggers, because the streets are wide and the area is middle-class, but the women take their daily runs in pairs or small groups, and the men usually run in pairs too. It’s probably as much a precaution against speeding or smartphone-distracted drivers as against criminals, but it does make sense. Now I don’t want to be misunderstood as blaming Fletcher or Durand for jogging or walking alone; Abston’s evil behavior is no one’s responsibility but his own. But the number of elderly, Asian, or other innocent pedestrians knocked down, mugged, or otherwise attacked on the streets of our cities in broad daylight is on the rise.

    Just today there was an incident in NYC in which an 82-year-old concierge was leaving the building where he works after his shift ended “when 20-year-old Deashe Calhoun lunged at him in an unprovoked attack, slashing him in the face [with a machete] at Stone Street and Broadway, MTA police and sources said. Calhoun was out free after seven prior arrests involving a machete or other weapons, including a similar attack just days ago, sources said.” Calhoun, BTW, is (or maybe identifies as) a female.

    https://nypost.com/2022/09/07/woman-randomly-slashes-man-82-with-machete-pepper-sprays-him-in-nyc/

  8. Running in a group is always better. Broken bones, heart attacks, automobiles, animals, weather, take their toll. We runners can be oblivious to risk. Sad and tragic sometimes so.

    In North Dakota, in the spring of 2011, a woman was running alone along a country road and was abducted and murdered. She also was a school teacher IIRC. The perps were caught BTW. They weren’t locals. Boom times brought bad folks.

  9. Some people commit crimes for economic gain, others like the piece of trash in the article do it because they love it

  10. Its not her farking fault its a rancidly corrupt legal political system that puts innocent people at the mercy of these predators and that brain damaged homunculus fetterman wants to spread this to the whole country

  11. Looking at the early-out judges and prosecutors from an imagined liability insurance point of view:
    Early out is described by various circumstances including nature of crime and perp’s history…. Look in the table…..
    Anything earlier than that and any crime committed comes to rest on the judge or prosecutor for very large sums. He files a claim.
    The premium is going to be….based in part on claims history. As would be the annual policy renewal.
    What behavioral differences would we see?

    Okay. From that hypo we can tell that the easy out folks don’t care what happens to the rest of us. Or maybe they enjoy the prospect.

  12. There is no other way to say it: the whole “there are too many people incarcerated” shibboleth is a load of BS a mile wide. We as a country need to prosecute more people and jail them for longer periods, and if that means doubling prison capacity, so be it.

  13. Update on the shooting spree: suspect in custody as of 10:25 pm; multiple squad cars and SWAT teams, as you’d expect.

  14. I live in the south and know a few people who have lived in Memphis either long ago (40+ years) or more recently (past 10 years). Both remark on how violent the city has become. The first group mourns, because they knew it before it was this way. The second group posts cynical memes like this one:

    https://i.pinimg.com/originals/ed/02/c7/ed02c745733718f38cfc5836e2163903.jpg

    In case the link doesn’t work, the text is:

    ‘I saw a parked car with a bumper sticker that said “I Miss Memphis.” So I shot out the windows, stole the stereo, slashed all the tires, and left a note that said “Hope this helps.”‘

  15. The French had a good idea at one time. Their penal colony was on remote islands off of Guiana, and effectively placed predators far from society. Whether or not it was a deterrent is another question; but, the extreme mortality rate did effectively thin the herd of society’s outcasts. The most notorious of the sites, although not necessarily the most brutal, was Devil’s Island. (Its notoriety stemming largely from the infamous Dreyfus affair.)
    Brutal? Yes. The penal colony was not designed for rehabilitation, it was intended to isolate the enemies of society.

    Being murdered and/or raped by a habitual predator is also brutal. So, I would advocate isolating anyone guilty of particularly brutal crimes; or anyone with multiple convictions for crimes against person, in an environment that is far removed from civilization. Since the risk to guards would be prohibitive, I would place this facility on a remote island, with patrol craft to prevent unauthorized entry/exit. The bare necessities of life could be dropped by helo. Initially anarchy would prevail. Eventually the strongest, most brutal would emerge as ruler. Much like many parts of the world today. The internal society would take on the characteristics of the jungle–which would be appropriate.

    Would we do this? Of course not. We will continue to wring our hands, and perhaps shed a tear, when innocent people are ravaged by predators that society does not have the will to control. We will continue to pretend that people with the instincts of wild animals are amenable to rehabilitation. Our large, and growing , underclass will continue to breed criminals; and our society will continue to degenerate.

  16. We as a country need to prosecute more people and jail them for longer periods,

    About 40% of all those convicted are remanded to state prison, where they serve a mean of 30 months ‘ere release. I suspect it would do more good to (1) clear out procedural bottlenecks, so cases are disposed of within a year if they go to a jury trial, within 10 weeks if a plea is negotiated; and (2) incarcerate all convicts bar those for which you substitute a corporal punishment. Fines should be for corporate offenders, offenses defined outside the penal code, or supplementary penalties for the most minor crimes. Restitution and forfeiture should be supplementary penalties. Labor services should be imposed on those who do not pay their fines, restitution, or forfeitures. The use of probation should be limited to convicts under 25, and should seldom if ever completely replace incarceratio. Also, be sparing with deferring punishment pending appeal, instead indemnifying people whose appeals were successful. Michael Kinsley’s speculation a generation ago was that ‘a year in jail, starting next week’ would be more of a deterrent that ‘playing roulette for 5-10 at some hazy point down the line’ I suspect is correct.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

HTML tags allowed in your comment: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>