Ulanova vs. all the other Juliets
Galina Ulanova was one of the most famous Russian dancers of the Soviet era. I saw her in person when I was very very young and she was close to 50 and nearing the end of her dancing days.
She was best in “real” roles where she played girls or women rather than sprites or fantasies. By the time the film I’m going to be highlighting here was made in 1954 she was 44 years old, no spring chicken in ballet terms, and the closeups aren’t kind (she was never a great beauty anyway). Films aren’t a good way to see ballet, but they’re all we have of Ulanova at this point.
Her proportions were not those of today’s ballerinas, nor of course was her technique or style, which some think is overdramatic. I don’t agree with that. She is always, always, always, expressing a character, never just doing steps and carefully showing off like so many of today’s dancers. Their emotional restraint and physical prowess were not her interests. She doth teach the torches to burn bright, even at the age of 44 without the forgiving distance a stage and theater provides.
The video I’m talking about is unfortunately unable to be embedded here; it must be watched at YouTube. So please go here and view minutes 21:24-23:00. This is a short variation where Juliet is introduced at the ball.
The second scene is from around 30:09 to 33:05 at the same video. It begins with a lift to which you should pay particular attention (you’ll see it again later, when she is an 86-year old teacher, in the next-to-last video I will post -and that one can be embedded, unlike this one). She originated the role of Juliet in this production. The male dancer, her Romeo, is a handsome guy but also far from a teenager or being able to pass as one. He’s not much of a dancer, either, although in those days standards for male dancers were very very different than now, and significantly lower. But he’s very much in the style of the time: strong and masculine. And boy, can he lift! The two of them make those lifts look like the easiest and most natural things in the world. They are most assuredly not (again, I refer to 30:09 to 33:05):
And here Ulanova is at 86, still showing em how it’s done:
No one today is even remotely like her. But then maybe no one was like her, even then.
Here’s a sampler of some excellent dancers of today – or of a little while ago (it’s not Ulanova who is number 2; that’s a mislabeling). They are so careful, so unspontaneous, and for the most part the tempos are slow and ponderous. I have to say, though, that the last dancer in the group, Ferri, is someone I saw in person, and this video doesn’t capture how wonderful she actually was in person. Very different from Ulanova, but still great:
I’m left awe-stuck by Galina.
The other women are passable – they all do the same moves as Galina, but seem awkward and mechanical.
I can’t say I know much about classical ballet, but I can recognize the Real Stuff when I see it. Are there any other fragments of Ulanove available, either on You Tube or elsewhere?
Good Ole Charlie:
Here’s another post I wrote about Ulanova, with videos.
Ulanova could have passed for a teen if it hadn’t been for the close-ups. I wonder if you have to be 44 to be that good, which is kind of hard on the younger, cuter dancers.
I rather liked the movie-realism (if R&J can be considered “realism”) of the Russian film.
Lots of fancy sets that you couldn’t do on the regular ballet stage, and bigger crowds.
Thanks, Neo. I always, always, ALWAYS enjoy your dance/ballet posts.
Ulanova’s lifts are just gorgeous. And whoever the second dancer is of the seven, her hands are a marvel.
Wow there is a difference in tempo for sure.
There is also an inherent difference between the film vs. stage clips. In the film, Ulanova ignores the camera and interacts with the people around her. There is certainly a lot more sprezzatura in her motions (especially arm motions and freedom from plumb-bob posture) but how much of the “stagey” apect of the other clips is a result of a frontal, stage-based performance?
That said – both directors and ballerinas should be taken to task for the lack of interaction between Juliet and the other revelers. At the very least, many of these background actors should have been less busy.
The only modern clips that seem to show any real interaction between Juliet and others (including Romeo) are Miyako Yoshida and Alessandra Ferri.
The only thing I know about ballet is that a lot of those moves that are part of every modern ballet dance were impossible until ballet dancers started doing them.
Beautify to watch. Thank you, Neo.
Another of the greats my friend took photos of!! [Maurice Seymour]
But the larger question was, did she lay down with prince Philip…