Yesterday I got something in the mail from the ACLU that purported to be a survey. But although it had questions – all leading, all assuming I was on the left – it was the cover letter that grabbed my attention. Here’s how it started:
Dear Friend:
All across our country, an intense struggle is underway over the future of the rights and freedoms we cherish.
I can’t argue with that; seems fair enough.
Emboldened by the Supreme Court’s overturning of Roe v. Wade, powerful forces in our country are driving to deepen their state-by-state assault on our civil liberties. They’ve made it clear they won’t stop until they’ve put abortion our of reach all across the country. And they aren’t stopping at abortion.
So they segue from Dobbs to the assertion that abortion will be banned everywhere if these nefarious unnamed “powerful forces” (which of course are understood to be the right) get their way. Of course, the lawyers at the ACLU are well aware that Dobbs actually gives each state control of its own policy on abortion, and that there is nowhere near majority support on the right for a national ban – and that Trump, for example, has made it crystal clear that he wouldn’t support one. But hey, it’s good fear-mongering for the left to assert otherwise.
And giving abortion decisions back to the states is just a gateway drug to the tyranny the right has planned for us all:
They’re attacking our right to use birth control and to vote.
No, they’re not.
They’re waging vicious assaults on the rights of transgender young people and using censorship and book banning to impose a whitewashed version of American history and current American reality on public school students.
The only “vicious assault” on transgender young people is the movement on the left to “treat” – with drugs and surgeries that often take away their “reproductive rights” to have children or to experience sexual pleasure – minors who lack the ability to consent. And the only strange and destructive version of American history and “current American reality” foisted on our young people is at the hands of the left.
The letter goes on it that general vein, segues into a pitch for donations, and then mentions the questions the survey will delve into. Note the way the conclusions are embedded in the questions:
– Are you concerned that, as state legislatures convene and as we look to the forthcoming elections, we are facing a new wave of efforts to ban abortion in state after state?
– Do you worry that racially motivated voter suppression could dilute the power of Black and brown voters in the 2024 presidential election?
– Are you alarmed by attempts across the country to censor talk about race and gender in our public schools, to muzzle schoolteachers, and to prevent students from having an open and equitable dialogue about our country’s history?
– Are you worried about efforts like the one in Texas to label gender-affirming medical cre as “child abuse” and to expose families to unwarranted government investigations?
After that, the letter goes on for some time about how the ACLU is fighting for abortion rights, and adds in bold letters for emphasis:
We don’t for a minute underestimate the seriousness of the threats we are facing – or the potentially devastating human impact of our opponents’ no-holds-barred assault. This upcoming election is not just about who will be president – it’s about our freedom, our future, and the trajectory of democracy.
Note the language in that first sentence, meant to panic women into feeling as though they and their children are under physical attack by the right and that it will only get worse: “threats,” “devastating impact,” “no-holds-barred assault.”
The ACLU and the Democrats know exactly what they’re doing with a pitch like this. They are purposely intensifying a primal type of fear. And I can assure you that the technique works. The women I know who are already voting for Democrats (and would never vote for Trump anyway) are fully energized to vote as though their lives and their children’s lives depended on it, and absolutely believe that the right is bent on the sort of program described in this letter and must be stopped at all costs. And from talking to some of them about this, I don’t think there’s anything that could change their minds.
And no, for the most part they are not and never have been radical leftists or especially politically oriented. For most of their lives, they voted for Democrats and followed the news in a surface manner, but didn’t hold especially radical views. And yet despite all of that, they accept radical moves on the part of the Democrats for whom they continue to vote, because pitches like the one in that letter strike them in very personal ways. The Handmaid’s Tale sort of scenario seems very real to them and exacerbates a primal fear of other people controlling one’s body and genitalia – and life – against one’s will. And the ACLU is one of many entities dedicated to fanning the flames of fear and dread.
Over last fifty or so years, women have become accustomed to abortion being legal everywhere, and states that are taking away what they see as a basic right feed into that fear, even if a woman lives in another state with unrestricted abortion. Harris’ recent Houston rally was an attempt to exacerbate that fear, as well. I think it may be that Draconian state abortion laws will backfire and cause the left to grow stronger.
I also believe that Trump’s approach is the correct one:
Trump, in the video, did not say when in pregnancy he believes abortion should be banned — declining to endorse a national cutoff that would have been used as a cudgel by Democrats ahead of the November election. …
While he again articulated his support for three exceptions — in cases of rape, incest and when the life of the mother is at risk — he went on to describe the current legal landscape, in which different states have different restrictions following the court’s Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization ruling on June 24, 2022, which upended the 1973 Roe v. Wade decision.
“Many states will be different. Many will have a different number of weeks or some will have more conservative than others and that’s what they will be,” he said. “At the end of the day it’s all about will of the people.”
But that’s nowhere near good enough for abortion absolutists on both sides. On the left we have those who want no restrictions, and on the right we have those who want an absolute ban.
On this blog I’ve discussed my own views on abortion many times, and so I’m not going to go into it again in any detail here. But I’ll add that, if we lose this election, I believe it will be due to this issue.